I wanted to thank you Chevalier for putting so much work into this game (and the first two)! It's been a pleasure reading through these illustrated depictions of tactical wargaming even though these are not games that I would want to play myself. For the Great War game, I think the biggest reason for your success was something that sounds simple but isn't: having the requisite patience not to act for long stretches of time. Most players, much like the real-life generals in the Great War, tend to get antsy and insist on doing something for the sake of doing something even when it isn't strategically wise. You did an excellent job of building up your forces to make decisive strikes and being perfectly content to have nothing take place on the Western Front for long months in-game / long weeks in real-life. A lot of lives could have been saved on the Western Front if the actual Entente commanders could have had the same strategic patience!
Chevalier Plays AGEOD Let's Play/AAR
|
It's a lot easier to be patient when you know the rules ahead of time, and it's not large parts of your actual country that's been occupied ...
I'll also appeal to this authority - well, at least someone more authorative than me - to defend some of the Entente actions in practice. Quote:Last time, we introduced the factors that created the trench stalemate in the First World War and we also laid out why the popular ‘easy answer’ of simply going on the defensive and letting the enemy attack themselves to death was not only not a viable strategy in theory but in fact a strategy which had been tried and had, in the event, failed. https://acoup.blog/2021/09/24/collection...stalemate/ Which does nothing to reduce the skill - and excellent reporting - shown by Chevalier in the game; I'd just be extremely cautious about applying the experience to real life.
It may have looked easy, but that is because it was done correctly - Brian Moore
(May 28th, 2024, 04:44)Cyneheard Wrote:(May 28th, 2024, 00:57)Brian Shanahan Wrote: One thing I meant to say the other day, the yellow flag you saw was a variation of the yellow-red-yellow flag of the Grand Duchy of Baden in use between 1848 and c.1866. Don't know why it popped up in this game. A number of the states which made up the German Empire retained their own armies (albeit largely under Prussian military discipline in peace time and under Prussian control in war). While Baden wasn't one of the states that retained it's army's independence (not being a Kingdom), at least two of the imperial army divisions were former Baden divisions. As such they retained some of their identity & insignia from independence and their unit flags. It's just kind of strange that the game uses a variation of the Baden flag that would have been more appropriate for the Austro-Prussian war of 1866.
Travelling on a mote of dust, suspended in a sunbeam.
|