WW15 - Chiron is a harsh mistress

[waterbat]

i completely understand Selrahc - but I do think its best for the village if I hold off posting until that point. I appreciate the sentiment though as I would call for the same.

[Serdoa]

I have to agree with Selrahc here. I don't see a reason why you need to hold back as of now and instead see several reasons not too if you are in fact a villager. Not telling anything is just giving me the feeling that you are in fact a wolf. Especially considering that as a name-seer, I expect you to know either that somebody lied about his name or that he did not. I hardly see how that information could in any way be harmful to the village if we knew it earlier. At best you found Lewwyns counterpart - I don't expect the wolves to kill him if he is either a wolf himself (as Lewwyn claimed) or a third party. But even if so, I don't see how that is harmful to the village.

Of course if you are not the name-seer but some other role, at least I would like to know your role now. Or are you believing that would also be harmful to the village?

[Jkaen]

Standard rule I never see any reason to break.

Don't role reveal during the night phase, it never helps villagers (with possible expection of 5 mins before deadline)

Is waterbat possibly going to state anything now that we cannot wait until daytime to hear?

[Molach]

...who Marr the alien really is?

[Serdoa]

Possibly yes, depending on the village-roles with active night-powers which might go to waste due to unknown facts. Apart from that, I do in general agree with you Jkaen. But he has already revealed enough that he will be a target for the wolves if he is a villager - and if he is a wolf and got the information through a scan performed by novice on Night 1 then it doesn't matter as well. So I fail to see how the rule you posted ("don't role-reveal in the night") applies in this case where he basically has already role-revealed and we discuss only about the information he can provide.

Btw: If he is a wolf, this might very well just be a try to get a possible baner to waste his ability on him.

[Jkaen]

To be fair if he his a name-seer (he hasn't 100% confirmed that). Then the only thing I am aware of him being able to do is solve Lewwyn's fight (which I don't believe we know all the details of).

If the wolves want to waste a kill on a name seer rather than taking out either somebody like zak, or possibly the baner (or heck the alignment seer), then I say let them.

[thestick]

...is waterbat actually the name seer? I don't think he actually stated it. Selrahc assumed that he was.

[Meiz]

Also, could the "mindworm-faction" please clarify if there abilities are indeed meant to be used with mindworms or if that are just additional abilities, for example something like "mindworm eater: You can eat a mindworm. Doing so will make you able to telepathically contact a player once in the night."

It's definitely not a "mindworm flavored" ability, in the way that Mattimeo's drone riot was just a fancy name for his ability.

[BRickAstley]

No Matt, why did you have to die. You were nice and helpful...

[Bobchillingworth]

So, we have two players who are now claiming "Drone" as their role? This in addition to the recently deceased Foreman of the Drones. That's a lot of Drones. Molach, can you also cause riots?