Serdoa Wrote:Injera, please explain that to me. You suspect Bigger because he asked someone to vote for his preferred target? Heck why don't you vote for me, I certainly did do the same in regards to Mattimeo.
No, it's because he's not really making his own case. I asked him state to thestick case in his own words and here was his response:
Bigger Wrote:agree +10 with this post. not with the catwalk part, but with thestick and uberfish parts.
Injera - about my thestick vote.
originally, it was 18 hours in and I'm not looking for a concrete argument (there aren't any). I don't think his original post was damning, but it was suspicious and there wasn't much to go on - also I feel like thestick gives off his tells best when he is under pressure, so he's a decent person to start a dogpile on. At that point I was looking more for his response than I was to lynch him. I was ready to hop off as soon as he made a townie post defending himself. His eventual response is more damning, though. I was expecting a village thestick to respond like he did in ww15 for being the top vote-getter - confused, a little panicky, "oh no, I don't understand why everyone is voting for me again." Instead I see ww13 thestick (when he was a wolf) - cool, calm, very sparse in his words, almost unaware that anyone is even voting for him. Also agree with Zak - thestick comes off as trying hard not to react to the votes against him, hoping if he stays mostly silent the village will get bored and pick a new candidate. That's a scum strategy, imo.
The +10 was referring to a Zak post. He brings some new insights, but I don't necessarily like them- it seems overstated. As someone who was reading the Neighbor thread in addition to the main thread last game he knows as well as anyone that thestick was legitimately absent for a while because he was busy. More importantly, though, he keeps falling back on Zak. Seriously, go take a look back at his posts and how many mention him.
I find the fact that he later tried to elicit whether Mattimeo could protect himself fishy as well.