waterbat Wrote:not defending the scumminess of those posts, but am a little confused how mafia Ichabod fits with what we saw at deadline. With mafia ichabod + mafia thestick not voting Bigger at the deadline, they had the ability to lynch bigger instead. why not? at least ichabod could have put a thestick vote in toward the end if they had given up on getting stick off of the gallows.
Valid point, I also considered that earlier.
Basically four options:
- He's scum but really wasn't online at the lynch deadline.
- He's scum but Bigger is also scum.
- He's scum but they figured that saving thestick just wasn't worth it. In particular, a last minute vote by Ichabod would have been very damning for him, considering his earlier promise to vote for thestick.
- I'm wrong, and he's innocent.
In general, I also agree with what Novice said: the wolves probably could have saved thestick if they went all in to do so, but that might not be the best long term play in a game with so many players. Better to lose one wolf than to expose the whole pack.
If you know what I mean.