On Qg - I agree on waiting to hear more until he has access to a better device to communicate with. What bothers me most his series of posts is how the quality degrades over time. It feels panicky. Does anyone remember if he was under significant pressure last game?
No, I didn't answer his question for him (and "miss the point.") I couldn't figure out what he was talking about so I searched his name myself to find out. As for searching his own name, it's possibly sketchy as it could be a cover for faking inactivity but feeling he needs to respond to direct accusations. We've seen new villagers play for survival instead of the village before, though.
The thing here is that you've written more posts than anyone else but novice despite being busy the first day. So you've spent time on the game, if you're a villager trying to win you should be trying to hunt wolves, or at least have some significant ideas. You're out here pressing about Mattimeo's power (which is just horrible for the village if Matt is a villager like you believe) when you could be hunting wolves.
Yeah, the big issue for me is that he was able to make the time to watch the end of day vote closely enough to catch the Mattimeo switch. That was a pretty small window of time- the whole thing from switch to wagon to claim to non-wagon took under an hour.
Not as active as you might think. More active than the lurkers, for sure, but a lot of his activity was involved in our squabble. After that was sort of resolved he disappeared until late vote, then he's been back a bit sporadically. That being said, I think the idea of specifically hunting less active or experienced players is a bad one. We have plenty of other stuff to go on.
Funny, the first thing I thought of when I saw your list was the list I made in WW14. If you think I seem like a wolf why did I not make your wolf team?
Like thestick was?
x-posted with Sareln and TT. Also, sorry for the long post, had to get caught up to a dozen pages.
uberfish Wrote:Waterbat and Injera: why are you answering my question for Arromir? Anyway you guys missed the point.
No, I didn't answer his question for him (and "miss the point.") I couldn't figure out what he was talking about so I searched his name myself to find out. As for searching his own name, it's possibly sketchy as it could be a cover for faking inactivity but feeling he needs to respond to direct accusations. We've seen new villagers play for survival instead of the village before, though.
Catwalk Wrote:Ugh, not nice putting me on the spot like that. I tend to piggyback other people's suspicions after a few mostly confirmed townies have been identified.
The thing here is that you've written more posts than anyone else but novice despite being busy the first day. So you've spent time on the game, if you're a villager trying to win you should be trying to hunt wolves, or at least have some significant ideas. You're out here pressing about Mattimeo's power (which is just horrible for the village if Matt is a villager like you believe) when you could be hunting wolves.
Bigger Wrote:If nothing else, it will tell us if he's guilty or not! But seriously, if we wait for Sareln to defend himself we might as well just agree to never lynch him! This is how Sareln always defends himself: say nothing, wait for the village to get bored and move onto another targetit mostly works.
Yeah, the big issue for me is that he was able to make the time to watch the end of day vote closely enough to catch the Mattimeo switch. That was a pretty small window of time- the whole thing from switch to wagon to claim to non-wagon took under an hour.
Bigger Wrote:ok, that makes much more sense. But Gaspar doesn't belong on either list, he's been plenty active as well.
Not as active as you might think. More active than the lurkers, for sure, but a lot of his activity was involved in our squabble. After that was sort of resolved he disappeared until late vote, then he's been back a bit sporadically. That being said, I think the idea of specifically hunting less active or experienced players is a bad one. We have plenty of other stuff to go on.
waterbat Wrote:[SIZE="4"]2) Injera: the Electrician[/SIZE]
Seemed like Injera the wolf to me. Perhaps I've played with him as wolf-buddy one time too many and just am colored by it.
Funny, the first thing I thought of when I saw your list was the list I made in WW14. If you think I seem like a wolf why did I not make your wolf team?
Mattimeo Wrote:I'm actually getting more of an impression of a villager going digging every time he posts. Can't help but think a wolf would have either stopped by now, or at least been fed some better points...
Like thestick was?
x-posted with Sareln and TT. Also, sorry for the long post, had to get caught up to a dozen pages.