Holy mother of something, that was a busy night. Yeesh. I didn't quote so I'm going from memory - stuff that stuck out for me overnight:
On to the main suspects:
Pindicator has no traction but I'll mention him since he was a big topic last night. He seems relatively disengaged. I agree that the sequence of actions was very scummy though he's pulled that gambit before. Though I think he might have been scum that time. Slight scum lean, I guess.
Sareln, I discussed above. I think he's town.
Selrahc is totally checked out, due to real life reasons I know its probably not easy for him to do anything but he's shown before he knows how to play lurker scum well. I also think he tilts at windmills more than anyone else and as such, wouldn't be missed that much if we end up wrong.
Twinkletoes89 sounds like himself. I do think the post uber highlighted seemed scummy but its hard to say really whether he's just caught up in paranoia or is scum. I lean the paranoia and hence town atm.
Ichabod I've banged heads with ad nauseum. I don't have a smoking gun, its just completely on tone. He sounds like wolf Ichabod. Lewwyn presented a more eloquent argument than I did. My only reticence is that anytime Lewwyn, novice and I agree on day 2, the world is probably about to end.
uberfish - just seems like the typical day 1/2/3 villager uberfish mislynch. He's aggressive which rubs people the wrong way and he's wrong alot, which also rubs people the wrong way. I think if we let him live though he might bag a mafia before all is said and done.
Anyway, money where my mouth is:
Ichabod
- Sareln definitely comes off innocent there - and man, be nice if we could ever get that level of participation from him without the noose halfway fitted.
- I do think a healthy dollop of skepticism is always required when novice is involved, though I've agreed with almost everything he's "said" today. There really are no confirmed town yet, one of these days we'll collectively learn this lesson and avoid getting punked by scum over and over.
- Just since its come up a few times, I have a strong town read on Azza.
On to the main suspects:
Pindicator has no traction but I'll mention him since he was a big topic last night. He seems relatively disengaged. I agree that the sequence of actions was very scummy though he's pulled that gambit before. Though I think he might have been scum that time. Slight scum lean, I guess.
Sareln, I discussed above. I think he's town.
Selrahc is totally checked out, due to real life reasons I know its probably not easy for him to do anything but he's shown before he knows how to play lurker scum well. I also think he tilts at windmills more than anyone else and as such, wouldn't be missed that much if we end up wrong.
Twinkletoes89 sounds like himself. I do think the post uber highlighted seemed scummy but its hard to say really whether he's just caught up in paranoia or is scum. I lean the paranoia and hence town atm.
Ichabod I've banged heads with ad nauseum. I don't have a smoking gun, its just completely on tone. He sounds like wolf Ichabod. Lewwyn presented a more eloquent argument than I did. My only reticence is that anytime Lewwyn, novice and I agree on day 2, the world is probably about to end.
uberfish - just seems like the typical day 1/2/3 villager uberfish mislynch. He's aggressive which rubs people the wrong way and he's wrong alot, which also rubs people the wrong way. I think if we let him live though he might bag a mafia before all is said and done.
Anyway, money where my mouth is:
Ichabod
I've got some dirt on my shoulder, can you brush it off for me?