Serdoa Wrote:@Qgqqqqq
Honestly? You tell us that you expect Lewwyn to die tonight (what means you suspect the same as me, that he is bloody right with Ichabod) and therefore you vote... for Selrahc? Not to say Selrahc is a bad target, but if you suspect Lewwyn is right with Ichabod, you should vote for him, not state "there are enough others on him", thats bullshit.
That said, I think Lewwyn makes a very good case. Additionally I didn't like all those posts by Ichabod. I unfortunately can't articulate myself as well as Lewwyn, but those posts reminded me strongly on the one time Ichabod was a wolf. Much text but at the end you have not gained any insight whatsoever. It is just noise, disguised as contribution.
Ichabod
I was away almost all day 1. Day 2 I spent the most time defending, which is villager play when you know you are a villager and I still made more contributions than a lot of players here.
Bigger Wrote:This is interesting. There were 5 people that made suspicious last minute switches to me (if you include Pindicator, whose vote was not to me but was meaningless, so COULD have resulted in my lynch). you mention two but not the most suspicious ones.
In fact I would say the voting pattern makes them suspicious in this order -
1. uberfish 2. sareln 3. merovich 4. catwalk 5. Pindicator.
Pindicator's neutral vote when he could have just piled on me makes him less suspicious. Pindicator had also previously voted for me so it still would have been near the end of the list even if he had hopped back on me. I put catwalk's near the end also because he had previously voted for me as well, unlike the first 3 that came out of nowhere.
Yes, this is Pindicator's MO, and while I was frustrated he wouldn't just vote for thestick, especially fearing a last minute wolf mislynch of me, its really not suspicious enough to warrant a lynch today. I think a day 2 lynch of Pindicator would be absolutely horrible, there are at least 6 better candidates (sareln, uberfish, ichabod, catwalk, selrahc, merovich - just thinking off hand) - the first 4 are screaming scum, at least.
You know, this is not as "tinfoil hat" as it appears at first glance. In any case, I completely agree with the second paragraph.
I'm not really happy with novice's play today at all. This whole post restriction is too coincidental anyway and doesn't really fit in with a mafia themed game, imo. It may very well be that village novice is faking it to avoid being night killed, but I still don't like it...
Lewwyn
as for lynch, I would actually be quite fine with Ichabod or uberfish lynching today, and I am very happy that we forced Sareln to start contributing -
but as long as the alternate candidate is alike Pindicator I'm going to have to stay on Sareln
What a wolf post...
Screaming Wolf?? I'm screaming wolf?? Really? Why!??! Because Zak said so??
Maybe we had 2 wolves on the spot on day 1, because this is just really bad. Screaming wolf... You don't even know what I'm being accused of, I bet... Blah, blah, blah, Zak's case, blah, blah, blah, screaming wolf.
Are we really going to let people sail thorugh the game so obviously like this?
Bah...