Of those three? I know you asked the question of him, but I think its a question anyone can answer (to their own opinion).
I think I can agree that a lot of the movement away from Sareln could have been Werewolf/based. As for myself, before Uberfish's 903 post of course, I saw the momentum switching to Uber (an equal suspect of mine, at that time, due to the similarity of the cases), and so I voted for him. That was when he got 6 votes really REALLY fast.
Anyways, CLEARLY there is a wolf influence in the pile because Sareln, in fact, was the start of the pile. So if he is a wolf (which I think he is) HIS involvement alone would make it wolf-influenced. And in one way or another, Novice/Catwalk/Waterbat followed suit.
I would be willing to believe that, between Sareln's reputation before I joined (he hasn't been early mislynched SINCE I joined, if I recall), and between Novice's largely villager appearance at the beginning of Day1, combined with Gaspar's GENEROUS contributions as to Sareln's "supposed innocence" wolf-Novice was able to have enough traction to possibly swing Catwalk and Waterbat his way.
Now, assuming a village/Catwalk, Catwalk is still convinced that Novice is our "most villagerish person" at the moment. This alone could be seen as somewhat scummy, I mean, yes I am aware that I am perhaps in the minority in thinking of Novice as a wolf for this game, but still most that due think village still keep a degree of reservation. Meanwhile Catwalk ... it seems like he is willing to take Novice's innocence on 'faith'. Now, from the opposite perspective, if NOVICE is a villager, for some strange reason, then it could be an easy Catwalk/wolf move to make to pretend like he "thinks" novice is the most trusted if he simply had a cheat sheet*
*of course I do not think that Novice is innocent, nor do I think that Catwalk is a wolf, per se, BUT if Novice IS somehow proven innocent, I think that would make Catwalk look a LOT more scummy.
So my answer then, is that although Catwalk and Waterbat are not anywhere near the level of "confirmed villager" I would say that the wolf-influence of the Pindi BW would be Novice and Sareln.
I think I can agree that a lot of the movement away from Sareln could have been Werewolf/based. As for myself, before Uberfish's 903 post of course, I saw the momentum switching to Uber (an equal suspect of mine, at that time, due to the similarity of the cases), and so I voted for him. That was when he got 6 votes really REALLY fast.
Anyways, CLEARLY there is a wolf influence in the pile because Sareln, in fact, was the start of the pile. So if he is a wolf (which I think he is) HIS involvement alone would make it wolf-influenced. And in one way or another, Novice/Catwalk/Waterbat followed suit.
I would be willing to believe that, between Sareln's reputation before I joined (he hasn't been early mislynched SINCE I joined, if I recall), and between Novice's largely villager appearance at the beginning of Day1, combined with Gaspar's GENEROUS contributions as to Sareln's "supposed innocence" wolf-Novice was able to have enough traction to possibly swing Catwalk and Waterbat his way.
Now, assuming a village/Catwalk, Catwalk is still convinced that Novice is our "most villagerish person" at the moment. This alone could be seen as somewhat scummy, I mean, yes I am aware that I am perhaps in the minority in thinking of Novice as a wolf for this game, but still most that due think village still keep a degree of reservation. Meanwhile Catwalk ... it seems like he is willing to take Novice's innocence on 'faith'. Now, from the opposite perspective, if NOVICE is a villager, for some strange reason, then it could be an easy Catwalk/wolf move to make to pretend like he "thinks" novice is the most trusted if he simply had a cheat sheet*
*of course I do not think that Novice is innocent, nor do I think that Catwalk is a wolf, per se, BUT if Novice IS somehow proven innocent, I think that would make Catwalk look a LOT more scummy.
So my answer then, is that although Catwalk and Waterbat are not anywhere near the level of "confirmed villager" I would say that the wolf-influence of the Pindi BW would be Novice and Sareln.