pindicator Wrote:The whole digging into Mattimeo's role thing was awful, just awful. Him and Catwalk both. Yes, you should not give anybody a free ride. But pressuring Mattimeo into revealing info that can help wolves and doesn't help the village? Just stupidI did think this info would help the village, though. Mattimeo had an unproven role claim and two good night targets had just been hit. Knowing if he used a charge or not was minimally useful to the wolves, I can't imagine that Mattimeo didn't use one. Knowing who he did protect was no use to the wolves either, wouldn't say anything about who he'd protect next (IMO). I would rather hear Mattimeo say who he protected each night rather than make up 3 targets 5 days from now when he mysteriously still hasn't been eaten. If he can wait until later to state his targets (and is scum, note that this is still entirely hypothetical) he can "pick" targets that make him look more pro-town. I thought pros and cons of this were both small. Minimal info for wolves, little bit of information for us.
This may well be bad reasoning, but those were my thoughts about it. Pretty much the only argument given against it was "OMG SHUT UP ALREADY AND STOP HELPING SCUM". I don't have a scum read on Mattimeo, so this is not an accusation now nor was it then. Just a matter of filing it away for later use, in case we get a reason to suspect him.