What did you miss about that pindicator? It's a "crap, we lost two townies post", what puzzles you about it? I do think that most theories concerning how wolves and townies would react to day and night end are useless, though.
Lewwyn, what exactly do you suspect me for? I'll remind you that you've found me scummy in just about every game we've played together (and the same has gone the other way, although I have tempered myself lately).
With half a suspect in Tasunke as well, too crazy to read but generating extreme noise in a very confident manner. He seems to be a bit embarrassed by that now, though.
Arromir for lurking outrageously and simply not contributing.
Merovech for dismissing suspiciion casually because "he knows he's town", and for his part in the lynch of thestick followed by suspecting everybody who helped lynch him.
Molach for having done a lurker wolf game before.
pindicator still stands out to me for not casting his vote on a suspect that had a chance of hanging, although he did later own up to that not being a good idea. Not sure if changing your mind is more scummy than stubbornly sticking with your position, both can make sense from both townie and scum perspective.
TwinkleToes for several reasons, including his dogged insistence on novice being scum (not just insistence that we shouldn't clear him but that novice actually is scum). He later confirmed his stance today by saying it'd take a lot to convince him to vote anyone else today.
I'm not saying these hunches are enough to hang any of these, I just found the sum of suspicion pretty big overall. I'm also not saying it's proof that Ichabod or pindicator is wolf, I just found it an interesting theory to pursue further. And I did cast my vote for one of the suspects on that list.
I still don't think saying "bad break for the village" is scummy, and I think it's an extremely weak argument for lynching. Is it that uncommon to use that kind of phrasing? And Lewwyn, you pretty much always think I sound scummy (I did notice your comment on the "village" argument).
I will be gone for a birthday party most of the day.
Lewwyn, what exactly do you suspect me for? I'll remind you that you've found me scummy in just about every game we've played together (and the same has gone the other way, although I have tempered myself lately).
Ichabod Wrote:What are the suspicious votes on Sareln you are talking about? This is the sort of comment that feels bad to me. You have a very meaningful conclusion that Pindicator or me was being protected due to the suspicious votes on Sareln, but you don't explain what are those suspicious votes.Ichabod, what I meant by that post is simply that I found most of the Sareln voters somewhat suspicious regardless of the Sareln vote:
Quote:Sareln - 8 - Mattimeo, Arromir, tasunke, Merovech, Molach, Pindicator, Twinkletoes89, Serdoa
With half a suspect in Tasunke as well, too crazy to read but generating extreme noise in a very confident manner. He seems to be a bit embarrassed by that now, though.
Arromir for lurking outrageously and simply not contributing.
Merovech for dismissing suspiciion casually because "he knows he's town", and for his part in the lynch of thestick followed by suspecting everybody who helped lynch him.
Molach for having done a lurker wolf game before.
pindicator still stands out to me for not casting his vote on a suspect that had a chance of hanging, although he did later own up to that not being a good idea. Not sure if changing your mind is more scummy than stubbornly sticking with your position, both can make sense from both townie and scum perspective.
TwinkleToes for several reasons, including his dogged insistence on novice being scum (not just insistence that we shouldn't clear him but that novice actually is scum). He later confirmed his stance today by saying it'd take a lot to convince him to vote anyone else today.
I'm not saying these hunches are enough to hang any of these, I just found the sum of suspicion pretty big overall. I'm also not saying it's proof that Ichabod or pindicator is wolf, I just found it an interesting theory to pursue further. And I did cast my vote for one of the suspects on that list.
I still don't think saying "bad break for the village" is scummy, and I think it's an extremely weak argument for lynching. Is it that uncommon to use that kind of phrasing? And Lewwyn, you pretty much always think I sound scummy (I did notice your comment on the "village" argument).
I will be gone for a birthday party most of the day.