Rowain Wrote:He used waterbats tool to get all my posts. So him missing soemis not really reasonable. The fact that he misses those that don't fit in his theory is very lucky for him isn't it.You really expect somebody to give a post by post review of circa 75 posts?
Quote:You do miss that I called Bigger suspicious for his BW- earlier before novice even made his post. Ichabod did find that why don't you and Gaspar?
Stating you find somebody suspicious and actually placing a vote on them, can be very different things. I am not saying it is a scum tell specifically. Even if you did find somebody suspicious, then once Novice had voted for them thought you may get traction on the vote, hence moved across to it. I agree that could well be a villager move, but your vote still followed Novice's
Quote:Yes but I did question first Qg whom I voted for at that time. And when I was finished with Qg I switched to pindicator with reference to his posting about which I already taked at night. I did question catwalk and waterbat to look for more talk than just pindicator is scum. And I did defend my vote vs pindicator.
My view, is any one or two of these questioning votes by itself is nothing, and what I would expect from any player. Its just so many back to back without your own conclusions that I think stood out to Gaspar (and me)
Quote:His accussation of piggybacking novice is wrong because I suspected Bigger before novice mentioned him and his accussation of no thought ofmayself is wrong because I talked about pindicator severaltimes. So he misses 2 points that speak against his theory. He also accusses Meiz wrongly which makes it 3 accussing posts by Gaspar with errorrs in them in all 3 cases.
I dont think a mention of sombody without any real push means a vote follow isnt piggy backing, you do. I also dont think its important anyway. I also think in that group of questions you dont present your arguments just ask for other peoples, regardless of who you mention during your questioning
Quote:Why are you defending him?
Erm because you asked me to. You said
Quote:What do you make out that Gaspar has misread posts/obmitted posts to make his attacks on Meiz and me?
so I answered your question.