WW16: The Outlaws and The Olives

[pindicator]

There's a silver lining. Wolves would have to assume Mero was telling the truth, so if Catwalk is a villager, those who were arguing that Mero was lying seem pretty villagerish to me.

If wolves assume he was telling the truth, wouldn't they want to lynch him? Night killing him would then take one of their own with him, if he had been honest.

Ah, we're back to Thestick's failure to vote bigger.

There were a whole lot of people who could have moved to bigger with thestick if they wanted to, we now have confirmed that there were enough town on that move to provide some cover - Sareln must have looked like an easy mislynch, I might have looked like one too at the time, and Mero initiated the move.

I think the probable scenario, then, is that the mafia were quite capable of saving thestick if they so chose but decided not to. Therefore I'm now leaning innocent on Catwalk. Pind gets no town cred for this, because he switched to Mero which could be an early attempt to frame the move as scummy.

Consider the scenario in which bigger was lynched and flipped town d1: it's highly likely that thestick would have been up on the block again soon enough. He could potentially have used his fake claim to try and fabricate a watcher guilty on someone, but I think it'd be hard for him to win that 1v1 without scum exposing themselves to support him.

So, then, if mafia decided to sacrifice a decently strong power role. there's no way they don't try to extract as much cover from that as possible by putting people on thestick's wagon.

It's like you read my last post, disregarded it, and then came to the same conclusion while still saying I'm scum.

Also, if catwalk ever turns out to be scum, you are so buddy buddy with him this seems over the top. To say you are "now" leaning innocent on him? You've been defending him all game! Actually, why does deciding the mafia chose not to save thestick give catwalk a village lean?


I also agree that the format here is daunting. I'm relieved that there are "only" 300-some posts to dig through in Day 3? That's nuts