WW16: The Outlaws and The Olives

[novice]

Part2

Befoer a short comment as I saw just novices post with the votes: Overdone vote-alyzing was what did cost the village WW14.
Nevertheless to continue: Day 1:
5 hours before lynch thestick is in the lead with 4 votes.
Then the Mattimeo-BW starts to run started by Serdoa (villager) comment he would vote Mattimeo do note that he votes thestick with that post. followed by uberfish(villager) that he would vote Mattimeo over thestick.

Then followed the first real vote: from pindicator then Sareln,Serdoa,uberfish (all 3 vill) and lastly TT.

Now we have 3 possiblities: a) Mattimeo is a fraud and we really had 2 wolves under the 3 topsuspects.
b) Mattimeo is real and pindicator used the comments from uber and Serdoa to make a run to save thestick. His later actions do support that (unvote, thestick, move to Merovech)
c) pindi is a villager but Matt is too are we really to believe that wolves sat on their hands happily lynching thestick? If no then of course TT is a wolf.

So to answer your question novice:
Yes pind is still high on my list: I would also be ok with a Tasunke and TT-lynch. Ichabod and Azza are currently second tier for me. And Mattimeo is a special case.

Excellent post, Rowain. And if we're doing a lazy lynch we should probably target someone who has contributed less than Rowain.

I agree that it would be odd if not a single wolf joined the Mattimeo wagon. TT has been excessively useless this game, overacting his paranoia. Easy cover for not doing any actual scumhunting, just hammer me and Uberfish for being obvscum.

I was going to follow up with a TT vote here, but when I went back and read his posts it just doesn't feel right. And then I remembered this series of posts:

Sorry, IRL surprised me today so no writeup anytime soon.

Merovech was lynched, he was a villager.

Bloody hell guys.

Good job the season finale of The Borgias was worth watching or I'd be even more pissed to log back in and see you all fuck up this vote

How do you know he's a fake claimer?

Fwiw, I think he might well have been telling the truth

Really makes me wish I had been around - I think the village has been misled and suckered.

If I had to bet, I would put it all on his claim being true

Novice, uberfish and Qgqqqqq

I am certain that at least one of you is a wolf, if not two.

Especially Novice & Uber, you were so quick to try and discredit Mero's claim and you were both explicit and vocal on getting the swing to lynch him.

Villagers, for fuck's sake look past these people and lets lynch one of them tomorrow.

If i survive the night (most likely) but still putting it out there.

I will tell you exactly why I believe Mero's claim

I really should read (and think) before I post.

My initial response was, by looking at the role was that it sounded right and that we were having one of those games (like we had in the past, I'm sure) where the GM didn't reveal the roles of villagers as they died - just said they were villagers and redacted the other bit.

Then I remembered the village blood brothers and I'll just shut the fuck up.

Nothing to see here, just a stupid, impulsive belief that I'd caught people out.

I dunno, call me gullible but I have a hard time seeing TT as wolf.

I'm also leaning village on Pindicator, so I guess that leaves two options:
a) Mattimeo is a wolf
b) The wolves are timezone-impaired.
c) The wolves were hell-bent on bussing Thestick. But why, when the first four voters were all village?

Gah.

unvote

And since that's no good, Ichabod. Good old wolfabod who was away during the last part of day 1 and couldn't help save his scum buddy.

Crosspost with JKaen and Meiz.