novice Wrote:But I'm still tempted to just lynch Mattimeo straight away - his protection choices coupled with the wolves audacity in choice of night kills stinks.
We ahve a tracker who screams out what his results were. I at least expected his 'null-read' to be a trap to catch a Cloaker who claims to have done nothing. As it is I do believe that both are true or to be precise out of the various possibilites I can imagine I think thats the most likely one.
waterbat Wrote:Lewwyn* and Qgqqqqq,
what about day3 when catwalk stayed in the lead until the very end when we (myself included) called for Mero to hang (and Mero subsequently claimed himself to death)?
Assuming that was the villager-led misstep it appeared to be, doesn't that make you think that catwalk is innocent? The mafia were just going to let catwalk go without a fight? Unless they came out in force in that last little Mero push, i don't see it.
Hmmm... Indeed, it may be worth it to lynch catwalk forthwith to get the information it gives. If mafioso, we certainly get some suspects in the Mero push. If villager, i think late Merovech movers get some cred there as it would seem an unnecessary risk for the mafia to move votes from villager to villager at such a late stage.
Not sure what I did to get on your scumdar, Lewwyn - but I'm sure you will let me know soon. If it is tied to the catwalk-mero thing, well, not sure what to say. I hope we hit a guilty party and if doing so makes me look incredibly bad, so be it.
catwalk
You believe that Catwalk is innocent but vote for him? Happy to lynch a villager? Your reasoning is also strange. If CW is a villager then we had 2 villagers up and scum will happily vote for whoever they can without earning looks. Which given Merovechs claim and the call to arms from both uberfish and novice means Merovech was a save spot to vote.