waterbat Wrote:You know - I wasnt moved at all by those arguments. I was moved by what i posted in the first vote on him. If we had 2 wolves up on the block on day 1, a lot of things fall into place. Why the push on a third innocent wagon (Bigger)? why thestick gave up the way he did. I just got a lot better feeling about day 1 if his alignment was mafia.
Without the push on him though, i just sigh and let it go. Yet another time one of my theories gets no traction, so great job seizing that opening guys!
I enjoy a good meta discussion fracas as much as anyone, but all the stuff about roll name and ability was mostly lost on me. Of course, re-reading mattimeo's posts didn't help me either - i truly was getting cold feet there.
Yeah, I wish I would have put the pieces together before that. I was certainly asked the question time and time again, but you put it together :D So kudos waterbat. Maybe I can take you down off my suspect list now,
But you're right, Mattimeo did a great job of acting the part - I was reading posts 751 & 752 by him at the end of the day and it was a great job acting by him.
If you would have made me choose at the end of the day, I would have said Mattimeo felt the most villager to me of all 3 of our claimers. I'm glad I kept my mouth shut at the end.
Suffer Game Sicko
Dodo Tier Player
Dodo Tier Player