novice Wrote:Impressions:
The buildup on Mattimeo was very organic.
I think Injera claimed to clear himself, not to save Mattimeo.
Ichabod's reasoning for shutting down the Mattimeo wagon made sense at the time. Gaspar and Pindicator seemed to work against the Mattimeo wagon. Jkaen was hesitant to get on.
Thanks for your analyses and for answering my questions
. I agree with your conclusions.waterbat Wrote:Injera, why claim with only 5/19 votes? With that much time left, you weren't in imminent danger.
Well that is bordering on unfair
If he waits longer then it is 'Hey why did you wait so long with your claim'. (Disclaimer thisis not a Injera is a villager post - it is only this specific point that I find unfair)
Jkaen Wrote:I am pretty sure we have been through this before, but ok.Me asking questions is how I get a feel for people. The questions and his answers are the reason why I voted Mattimeo and not Qg yesterday. Without them I would not have gotten the village-impression of Qg I had because his other play was/is rather scummy.
The main section that I think you refer to that I found scummy was where you had lots of posts all in a row asking questions.
I also think that my questioning Qg plays a role why novice thought him village enough to lynch the cloaker. (Don't forget novice voted for Qg before I started my questioning).
Besides and this is a point of interest for me: On day 2 I stated my case vs Pind but although pindi got a lot of votes you were not on him. On day 4 I stated the same case again and now you were happy to campaign for his hanging. What changed your mind?
(and no this is not an accussation - IMO it makes it hard to see you both as scum and at the moment I would rather lynch pindi than you).