Long day here. I've read everything (I think) and I have to say I don't have too much to add. I primarily agree with most of what novice had to say. He did a lot of the work in vote compilations and it makes it pretty easy to see where we get a bit of a start of our suspect pool. Now novice does lead focus away from final Mattimeo voters but I don't think we can fully absolve them. However novice is likely right that the wolves are like non-Matt voters. Its a bit of a catch 22. We can't examine everyone, so we have to pick the more likely group to start with.
Of everyone left, the people I trust most are novice, Meiz, waterbat and catwalk. Feels odd to say Catwalk but I simply see no way for him to be a wolf. Likewise waterbat who I examined yesterday and convinced me of his villageryness.
Now:
This is slightly paranoid in my mind. I actually think its more likely the wolves will kill one of the two power role claimers, if they are villagers. I don't think the wolves can afford not to kill them if they are villagers actively watching for night kills.
Of everyone left, the people I trust most are novice, Meiz, waterbat and catwalk. Feels odd to say Catwalk but I simply see no way for him to be a wolf. Likewise waterbat who I examined yesterday and convinced me of his villageryness.
Now:
Twinkletoes89 Wrote:Seen as novice was critical in leading the swing, I expect that if he is innocent that he will die tonight. If not, people really need to start thinking why. I'm nowhere near as good a catherder as he is, so if he is innocent, he is much more dangerous to the mafia than I am
This is slightly paranoid in my mind. I actually think its more likely the wolves will kill one of the two power role claimers, if they are villagers. I don't think the wolves can afford not to kill them if they are villagers actively watching for night kills.
“The wind went mute and the trees in the forest stood still. It was time for the last tale.”