Tasunke Wrote:Ichabod, do I really have to tell you that while YES, good players tend to look wolfish even if village, there are still traits of distinguishability?
Perhaps sufficiently competent werewolf players (as village) are highly similar to sufficiently competent werewolf players (as scum) ... but you really seem to be doing a lot of defending lately. Especially of mattimeo ...
Yes, I know post 2223 was a joke, but there ARE ways of hunting wolves, and I would dislike attempts to make people forget that.
Tasunke Wrote:Glad I read this, as it can be answered quite readily.
At this point in time I was already (and perhaps foolishly) beginning to heavily suspect Sareln and Uberfish.
I saw the Mattimeo push, therefore, as a wolfish plot for some reason or another. Therefore, to counter it I immediately voted the stick. (I was going to hesitate, but I had thought that hesitation may have led a "villager" Mattyboy to hang on a lupine cross, as it were)
After my vote, I looked for signs of TheStick's innocence within his posts. Even though I was certain of Sareln's and Uberfish's "guilt" I had no real read at the time of TheStick's alignment.
However, upon re-reading TheStick's posts I saw no sign of innocence, and managed to convince myself of his guilt.
Once he flipped wolf, this made me more confident than ever of Sareln and Uberfish's guilt because it was for THEM that I voted against them (onto TheStick).
However, now that it appears BOTH were wolves, I can only see my logic on day 1 (and day 2) as both arrogant and foolish.
Is it just me or this night 4 is the first time in the whole game (may I actually say games) that you took such a defensive posture, Tasunke?
My comment was just a joke on a famous quote, that I felt like doing because I'm in a good mood regarding this game (for now). You can be sure that I won't let Novice or other whatever other player go because he voted for someone. But, truth be told, even if Novice is really a wolf, he helped the village more than a lot of villagers.