Ichabod Wrote:And I'm still waiting to hear why Novice feels Lewwyn is more innocent than the other Mattimeo voters.
Sorry, forgot to respond to this (again).
Lewwyn just ends up on the villager end if I rank the non-Mattimeo voters based on other evidence and gut feeling. Lewwyn has come across as more contributing than, for example, Gaspar. Whereas Gaspar makes thoughtful posts on the game as a whole, he hasn't gotten into many specifics on suspects. Lewwyn, otoh, made a detailed accusation against Catwalk (which I disagreed with, but he seemed earnest). You should remember it Ichabod, you said Lewwyn's case "made things click" for you.
I have to run.