Twinkletoes89 Wrote:There are two theories on novice being kept alive IMO.
1) He's mafia.
2) The mafia have some kind of name-seer/weakened role scanner. Zak was always going to die night one, and they scan Serdoa on a the first night, see blood brother and go after him to get 2 kills.
Third night, Qgqqqqq reveals a threatening role to them, so they kill him before he has the chance to catch any mafia.
Fourth night, they are suckered into believing that Rowain is unlynchable and so kill him, thinking that if they don't, the village will finally have a confirmed villager.
Two is feasible, as otherwise I cannot see why they would not kill Novice on night two, especially as he was 'post restricted' so couldn't leave much of a helpful trail to other mafia.
Number 2 is wrong, because Qgqqq was killed on night 4. uberfish was killed on night 3. Not sure how this fares for your argument.