I thought calling it a clusterfuck was reasonably polite, my apologies if you feel otherwise 
And I still think it was (both polite and a clusterfuck). Enough votes to hang him, yes. Enough votes to hang him by enough votes that scum can't easily control the vote, no. Azza had votes already and there was momentum on him, yet with 7 minutes left (not 5 as earlier stated, and if we start with Ichabod's vote it's 9 minutes) we start putting votes on someone with no votes. You say yourself that Azza was high on your suspect list. This was the final tally:
I also find it telling that you're distancing yourself from the Azza vote:
Lastly, saying that you "wanted to test the judgement of current Azza voters" seems strange to me. I assume you're referring to your last vote here. How is this a test of judgement? Either he's guilty or not, and we're guessing regardless. You can test people's reactions by switching votes, I don't see how it makes sense to argue that you're testing their judgement.
My case on you hinges on Azza being scum, I see no reason to go after you first and I still find Azza an excellent candidate. If he flips scum, I think you look very bad. Again, no offense intended by any of this and I apologize if you feel any of it was out of line. I'm officially not following you around anymore, though
And I still think it was (both polite and a clusterfuck). Enough votes to hang him, yes. Enough votes to hang him by enough votes that scum can't easily control the vote, no. Azza had votes already and there was momentum on him, yet with 7 minutes left (not 5 as earlier stated, and if we start with Ichabod's vote it's 9 minutes) we start putting votes on someone with no votes. You say yourself that Azza was high on your suspect list. This was the final tally:Quote:Meiz - 5 - Azza, tasunke, Gaspar, Twinkletoes89, IchabodThere was plenty potential for hanging Azza with at least 7 votes, maybe 8. If Azza flips scum eventually, I will likely find it highly suspicious that you called him a villager for a long time then *almost* helped hang him but obfuscated it at the finish line.
tasunke - 5 - Pindicator, Selrahc, Injera, Waterbat, Catwalk
Azza - 3 - Lewwyn, Meiz, novice
Selrahc - 2 - Molach, Jkaen
I also find it telling that you're distancing yourself from the Azza vote:
Quote:So why did I vote the way I did? I voted for my stated suspects all the time, the only exception being AzzaYet in your suspect list in the same post is 3rd from the bottom based on post scumminess alone. I will have to reread, but I recall you saying several time that Azza read villager to you. Lo and behold, in your next post you've found reasons to bump Azza up to 5th place.
Lastly, saying that you "wanted to test the judgement of current Azza voters" seems strange to me. I assume you're referring to your last vote here. How is this a test of judgement? Either he's guilty or not, and we're guessing regardless. You can test people's reactions by switching votes, I don't see how it makes sense to argue that you're testing their judgement.
My case on you hinges on Azza being scum, I see no reason to go after you first and I still find Azza an excellent candidate. If he flips scum, I think you look very bad. Again, no offense intended by any of this and I apologize if you feel any of it was out of line. I'm officially not following you around anymore, though