waterbat Wrote:TT, assume novice is a wolf and we know it right now. You said this would allow us to go back and determine what he was trying to do. Can't you do that analysis now? Assume he's wolf and see if the actions he's done fit with that assumption.
Hmmmm. Looking over the final vote tallies is so frustrating. 6 days of data and nothing stands out to me.
There's a huge distance between assumption and actual knowledge. We can assume all we like and we can easily twist novice's posts into a villager or mafia light - that's the whole damn point of the game he is playing (if he is mafia)
And you make my central point with your last statement - no stand out data.
A lynch of novice would give us no end of data. I think its 99.999% established that I'm a villager. So even if I am wrong and he is village when we kill him, we can look at the others joining me and potentially find wolves.
And we do need a big play now. We need a big dose of information while we actually have time and lynches left to use it. Rowain's play bought us some extra time, now let us use it.
"You want to take my city of Troll%ng? Go ahead and try."