Remaining players:
novice
Meiz
Waterbat
Pindicator
Lewwyn
Catwalk
Gaspar
Jkaen
Twinkletoes89
Assume novice, TT, Catwalk innocent. That leaves 5, not counting myself. Gun to head on most likely to least likely scum:
Pindicator
Lewwyn
Jkaen
Meiz
Waterbat
Its pretty much a dead heat between Pindicator and Lewwyn for most likely. Pin has had the overall more scummy game, Pin has also had more "village moments" and has had the feel of being propped up for mislynch. I also give a slight tick to Lewwyn for the fact that I think he's scum every game and have been wrong every time. I keep waiting for his big moment which never seems to be forthcoming, but that burned me on Meiz (albeit from the lurker thread) last game. I guess bottom line I can talk myself into and out of everyone.
Jkaen/Meiz is pretty much a dead heat - neither has stuck out as either wolfy or villagey this game. Jkaen's thoughts when proffered have lined-up more readily with my own, but I never agree with Meiz. Instinctively I think the wolves would have used red herringed at least one post restriction, but that's really is just as likely pindicator as Meiz. I basically disagree with Meiz on most substantive discussions, but that's par for the course as well.
Waterbat, I've just never got a solitary scum vibe from him. But I thought he was playing to worse village game of all time last game when in fact he was playing a brilliant scum game. So I could be underestimating him.
I guess that doesn't say much, mostly I'm trying to collect my own thoughts. I want to be sure of something but I've basically felt totally unsure all game over everything. Anyway, if you force me to name a mafia den I think its Pindicator, Lewwyn and Jkaen, but I basically could be talked into and out of any mix of those 5. I'll stick with Pin but I do feel a bit like maybe I'm not following my own advice.
novice
Meiz
Waterbat
Pindicator
Lewwyn
Catwalk
Gaspar
Jkaen
Twinkletoes89
Assume novice, TT, Catwalk innocent. That leaves 5, not counting myself. Gun to head on most likely to least likely scum:
Pindicator
Lewwyn
Jkaen
Meiz
Waterbat
Its pretty much a dead heat between Pindicator and Lewwyn for most likely. Pin has had the overall more scummy game, Pin has also had more "village moments" and has had the feel of being propped up for mislynch. I also give a slight tick to Lewwyn for the fact that I think he's scum every game and have been wrong every time. I keep waiting for his big moment which never seems to be forthcoming, but that burned me on Meiz (albeit from the lurker thread) last game. I guess bottom line I can talk myself into and out of everyone.
Jkaen/Meiz is pretty much a dead heat - neither has stuck out as either wolfy or villagey this game. Jkaen's thoughts when proffered have lined-up more readily with my own, but I never agree with Meiz. Instinctively I think the wolves would have used red herringed at least one post restriction, but that's really is just as likely pindicator as Meiz. I basically disagree with Meiz on most substantive discussions, but that's par for the course as well.
Waterbat, I've just never got a solitary scum vibe from him. But I thought he was playing to worse village game of all time last game when in fact he was playing a brilliant scum game. So I could be underestimating him.
I guess that doesn't say much, mostly I'm trying to collect my own thoughts. I want to be sure of something but I've basically felt totally unsure all game over everything. Anyway, if you force me to name a mafia den I think its Pindicator, Lewwyn and Jkaen, but I basically could be talked into and out of any mix of those 5. I'll stick with Pin but I do feel a bit like maybe I'm not following my own advice.