(October 17th, 2012, 18:07)novice Wrote: That is an interesting find, Pindicator.
So who's left?
TT, Catwalk, Novice, Gaspar, Waterbat, Pindicator, Jkaen, Meiz.
I reread the last 24 hours (didn't take long) and Waterbat looks quite bad. Gaspar is still a plausible suspect, too.
I said earlier that I could only see Catwalk as scum if he was partnered with Lewwyn. So you can remove Catwalk from my villager list.
No point in being coy, I think we'll have to lynch one of those three tomorrow. My instincts say that the rest of the gang are villagers. Maaaybe I could get behind a Jkaen lynch.
So Waterbat > Gaspar > Catwalk > Jkaen.
Looking forward to a Meiz dossier on Lewwyn's posts.
In all fairness, can you honestly put yourself in a plausible scenario where I'm scum unless Meiz is as well? If I'm mafia, I hang out on Pindicator and let you cast the deciding vote where I have a 50/50 chance of you hitting a villager as opposed to casting the killing vote on scum. If Meiz is village and he hung today, scum are 1 mislynch away where they only need to con one villager into voting wrong.
Anyway, not going to defend myself anymore but I find it annoying that when I vote poorly I hear it about voting poorly and when I vote correctly I somehow still hear it about voting correctly.
I think the scum have to come from Jkaen, Waterbat, Catwalk at this point unless Meiz is scum in which case we learned nothing. If we had another mislynch left I could talk myself into a Meiz test but at this point all the circumstantial evidence points to Meiz' innocence. Given I've had village reads on both Catwalk and Waterbat all game, and a basically null read on Jkaen, I guess I'm basically an idiot. Still, I'd like to be a winning idiot - so let's take advantage of the evidence in front of us.