(October 19th, 2012, 10:20)Twinkletoes89 Wrote: Sigh
Look TT, despite what everyone around here seems to think there is functionally no difference between awarding mayor to a villager with poor judgement and scum. You've had some good moments this game but if it were up to you novice would have been dead on day 3 and we'd probably already be looking at a scum win. And this is a constant theme for you - your level of paranoia is healthy contribution for the village but it doesn't bode well for a mayor role which could be the difference between victory and defeat.
I was on Pindicator as much as anyone but it is pretty darned difficult to believe after yesterday that he's scum without some damning new information. If he is scum, well then I'm really going to be kicking myself black and blue in the post-game thread. And if nothing else I trust him to build consensus and not abuse his power. Do I think I'm a better choice? Yes. But I can live with Pin.
I'm not sure what to say right now - I think we have 3 possible candidates today and I feel pretty strongly that Jkaen and Waterbat are better options than Catwalk. But I'm open to be convinced if someone has something convincing to say.