(October 22nd, 2012, 13:30)pindicator Wrote: Gaspar
You keep talking about process, so in your opinion which path has the least risk to village as being wrong? Taking into account there are possibilities of 2 scum & 1 scum, who makes sense as a wolf pair to you? Using that, what's the best way to proceed? I am considering voting for you just because of the reason of processes: point being that if there are 2 scum, I've got you as the scum partner. See my post at the beginning of the day for details. Would like a response from you about this.
Also - now you don't trust me as much as you did yesterday? I'm unclear from your post; you aren't attacking me, but your mayor vote seems to say you have more doubts now than you did yesterday.
(October 22nd, 2012, 17:23)pindicator Wrote: Gaspar, if you think waterbat is soft-pedally Meiz's attack, then who do you think is his wolf partner?
Second question first, it seems like he's trying to soft-pedal his attack because he is Meiz's scum buddy. Basically using the same argument as Waterbat attacked me with you apply it to Meiz and it actually rings truer. He said that I was on him but Meiz was on him all day and actually voted for him. Basically he needs to invent a case against me and easy enough to just ignore Meiz and hope people ignore it too.
On trusting you, well not exactly. Nothing has really changed but the odds. You were convinced I was village yesterday and are now heavily considering voting for me. When there's 5 left and there could be 2 scum, you have to consider everyone. But right now you're the one I'm most sure of as innocent.
Bottom line is if there's one scum left, I'm almost certain its Waterbat. Catwalk is an excellent second choice if I weren't feeling so strong about Waterbat. I do not believe either you or Meiz would be lone scum at this point.
If there are two scum left, I rank the likelihood as 1) Waterbat/Meiz; 2) Waterbat/Pindicator; 3) Meiz/Pindicator. This is mostly after watching today flesh out, which is probably our best indication of buddying. I think Meiz and Waterbat have deliberately avoided attacking each other after doing so for some time. That strikes me as suspicious. If they were the last two scum, they'd want to avoid a situation where they were the last two on the block. If they can get it to come down to Waterbat vs you or me, they just bonk on to whichever one of us picks up a vote at the deadline and that's ballgame.
But watching Waterbat's tour de scum above just cinches it for me. He's either a lone wolf or in a pair with Meiz and I'd be shocked at any other outcome.