(October 23rd, 2012, 10:10)waterbat Wrote: Gaspar, please if you are village, don't ask yourself "who would I rather not lose to?" and answer waterbat.
Pindicator, same request.
You've both intimated that is motivation. This is a ridiculous cop out!! don't want to be bested by the most obvious wolf ever again. I get it, but it shouldnt matter. A loss is a loss and you will have put in all this time and effort for nothing. I've got the opposite problem, as I know who I'd rather lose to at this point, but don't have to worry about it unless we make it to tomorrow.
At least Meiz took the time to come up with a case. Like earlier in the game when he first pushed me, I appreciate the effort.
Meiz - we all put Gaspar in our list of suspected persons. someone is lying about it... someone who didn't follow up their suspicion with a vote. Are you going to be available up until deadline, and what do you want to see from me to prove my innocence?
Well, not for nothing, but I'm not voting for that Gaspar guy, I'm 100% sure he's innocent.
And its not a ridiculous cop-out: I'm not saying I don't want to lose to you because I don't want you to win - you seem like a decent enough guy, I don't begrudge you personally - I'm saying I don't want to lose by voting for anything other than my strongest scum read. You are my strongest scum read. So that's where I'm voting. If I move off you to, say Meiz and I'm wrong, that would be infuriating. That's all I'm saying.
I know the question wasn't posed to me but I'm not sure what you could do to convince me of your innocence at this point, such is the degree to which I'm convinced of your scumminess. But I'd say your best and only shot at this point is to convince us that someone else is scummier. So that's where I think you should be focusing your efforts. We've all heard your defense for several days now and I think all 4 of us find in unconvincing. Even the only person not voting for you has you at worst second in their "list of probable scum" so your current methods aren't working.
Of course, while I'm happy to engage you as a villager, Occam's Razor says the above is probably true because you are indeed scum.