well ive been typing this up as you've been talking about me. I'll respond to those in a sec.
waterbat signs:
post 80: My first serious vote hits upon a wolf (thestick)
post 81: I go back to WW15 to pull out a comment from wolf Molach - which is crazy because he actually followed this pattern. Why would I bring out a fellow wolf's MO if he was planning on following it?
post 636: in my large list - I again read molach as scummy - noone cares or responds to it because its buried in my huge list of players. Another thing - why would I compile that requested list if I was scum? I'd ignore the request or do a half assed job at it.
post 698:
As scum, I'm damning myself here by jumping on with Ichabod in defending Mattimeo.
post 1744: so after earlier defending Matt with Ichabod, suddenly I decide that Day 1 starts to make a LOT of sense if Mattimeo is scum. I vote him and at one point am only voter on him.
post 1931 - calling out the lack of movement on catwalk's wagon during earlier day really rang village for me and gave me doubts about my vote. I move off of him to Qgqqqqqq. Why would i do that? If catwalk is village as we suspect - why switch at that time and grab attention for it?
post 2017: i do a re-reading of ALL Qgqqqqq posts. As I am posting it, he claims, basically rendering all of my work useless, but i post it anyway. I didn't fabricate a case! I admittedly put in there that the re-reading didn't give me a read.
post 2078: move back to Mattimeo - helping seal his fate. There's no way I put him in danger like that - he wasnt going to hang without the late movement. I pushed him all day - definitely not a "he's going down, lets bus him" play
post2125: cold feet on mattimeo as we are waiting for the deadline to eclipse. It seemed too easy.
--- im going to stop right there for now ---
I skipped a post:
post number: 2128 rb_post_id: 297693 poster: waterbat
TT already made the deciding vote, Molach.
why would i prevent Molach from trying to gain credit??
I think day 4 holds the answer for me:
checking the totals on the Mattimeo day, Novice was very confident that Mattimeo was not bussed. Take a look at this total:
[SIZE=large]DAY FOUR
Mattimeo - 8 - novice, Waterbat, Catwalk, Meiz, Ichabod, Rowain, Twinkletoes89, Molach
Qgqqqqq - 5 - Selrahc, tasunke, Gaspar, jkaen, Mattimeo
Injera - 2 - Qgqqqqq, Pindicator
Catwalk - 2 - Injera, Azza
Selrahc - 1 - Lewwyn
Arromirwas mod-killed for inactivity.
Qgqqqq was night-killed. Injera followed Azza with no result.
Later it was pointed out that Mattimeo could have been bussed because Molach was on him.... But as I POINTED OUT Molach didnt make the decision - it was already done. The answer is right there in day 4 tally: waterbat catwalk meiz very likely villagers.
waterbat signs:
post 80: My first serious vote hits upon a wolf (thestick)
post 81: I go back to WW15 to pull out a comment from wolf Molach - which is crazy because he actually followed this pattern. Why would I bring out a fellow wolf's MO if he was planning on following it?
Quote:Originally Posted by Molach
My wolf MO - build trust early, later on in the game when it becomes difficult to talk about anything without giving away oneself or fellow wolf enter lurk mode. Lurking at start of game is kinda stupid for wolves - it's noticable and not needed as there is plenty to talk about.
We should look for 'blenders' rather than lurkers. Blending in by posting fluff and safe votes, not silence. Anyway.
post 636: in my large list - I again read molach as scummy - noone cares or responds to it because its buried in my huge list of players. Another thing - why would I compile that requested list if I was scum? I'd ignore the request or do a half assed job at it.
Quote:7) Molach: the Street musician
one post struck me as odd:
Quote:Originally Posted by Molach
So if stick flips mafia then we should have a lot to work on tomorrow. And something as well if he is village - passive followers and such.
. That seemed like trying a bit hard to distance himself from the knowledge that thestick was indeed a wolf. I dont know - only 6 posts or so - not much to go off of.
post 698:
Quote:Quote::Was hoping you'd come back to that post. It's what makes it hard for me to doubt Mattimeo's innocence. That and the push on Matt which seemed an attempt to derail thestick's appt with the noose.
Originally Posted by Ichabod
Sorry to spam the thread, but post 200 by thestick is a very compelling evidence towards Mattimeo's innocence (I was starting to think his claim could have made to save him in detriment of the lesser power role in thestick). but that one post is very difficult to fit in a "Mattimeo is a wolf theory".
As scum, I'm damning myself here by jumping on with Ichabod in defending Mattimeo.
post 1744: so after earlier defending Matt with Ichabod, suddenly I decide that Day 1 starts to make a LOT of sense if Mattimeo is scum. I vote him and at one point am only voter on him.
post 1931 - calling out the lack of movement on catwalk's wagon during earlier day really rang village for me and gave me doubts about my vote. I move off of him to Qgqqqqqq. Why would i do that? If catwalk is village as we suspect - why switch at that time and grab attention for it?
post 2017: i do a re-reading of ALL Qgqqqqq posts. As I am posting it, he claims, basically rendering all of my work useless, but i post it anyway. I didn't fabricate a case! I admittedly put in there that the re-reading didn't give me a read.
post 2078: move back to Mattimeo - helping seal his fate. There's no way I put him in danger like that - he wasnt going to hang without the late movement. I pushed him all day - definitely not a "he's going down, lets bus him" play
post2125: cold feet on mattimeo as we are waiting for the deadline to eclipse. It seemed too easy.
--- im going to stop right there for now ---
I skipped a post:
post number: 2128 rb_post_id: 297693 poster: waterbat
TT already made the deciding vote, Molach.
why would i prevent Molach from trying to gain credit??
I think day 4 holds the answer for me:
checking the totals on the Mattimeo day, Novice was very confident that Mattimeo was not bussed. Take a look at this total:
[SIZE=large]DAY FOUR
Mattimeo - 8 - novice, Waterbat, Catwalk, Meiz, Ichabod, Rowain, Twinkletoes89, Molach
Qgqqqqq - 5 - Selrahc, tasunke, Gaspar, jkaen, Mattimeo
Injera - 2 - Qgqqqqq, Pindicator
Catwalk - 2 - Injera, Azza
Selrahc - 1 - Lewwyn
Arromirwas mod-killed for inactivity.
Qgqqqq was night-killed. Injera followed Azza with no result.
Later it was pointed out that Mattimeo could have been bussed because Molach was on him.... But as I POINTED OUT Molach didnt make the decision - it was already done. The answer is right there in day 4 tally: waterbat catwalk meiz very likely villagers.
--
Best dating advice on RB: When you can't hide your unit, go in fast and hard. -- Sullla
Best dating advice on RB: When you can't hide your unit, go in fast and hard. -- Sullla