I'm pretty decided on Gaspar for today, but I think that you're digging your own grave with this line of reasoning waterbat. pindicator and Meiz both stated reservations about that approach.
I'm still lobbying for Gaspar, though. I think there is real evidence against him that cannot easily be explained by calling him a bad villager (he's anything but), whereas waterbat looks more and more like a confused/foot-in-mouth villager being set up for a mislynch. If there are two wolves left and one of them is Gaspar, I'm starting to lean towards the other one being Meiz or pindicator. More likely Meiz as pindicator has quite strong town cred. waterbat/Gaspar as scum is still a possibility, but I don't think waterbat's play last two days fits that.
I'm still lobbying for Gaspar, though. I think there is real evidence against him that cannot easily be explained by calling him a bad villager (he's anything but), whereas waterbat looks more and more like a confused/foot-in-mouth villager being set up for a mislynch. If there are two wolves left and one of them is Gaspar, I'm starting to lean towards the other one being Meiz or pindicator. More likely Meiz as pindicator has quite strong town cred. waterbat/Gaspar as scum is still a possibility, but I don't think waterbat's play last two days fits that.