Y'know, I just gave the day a re-read and I think the player contribution I like least is Bigger's.
I still don't like his initial reactions to accusation on day one and while gave him a pass because it felt like he was trying, it reminds me of my play in the long game (16?) where I was quite chatty to start and lost steam as time went on. Then basically all he does today is a bit of buddying and attacking the low-hanging fruit (PB, Mattimeo.) While I'd buy that Mattimeo could be scum because anyone could be scum when they're lurking as much as he is, his whole play just feels lazy. Which I would be if I were scum and the lead candidate was innocent and being lynched by villagers.
I still don't like his initial reactions to accusation on day one and while gave him a pass because it felt like he was trying, it reminds me of my play in the long game (16?) where I was quite chatty to start and lost steam as time went on. Then basically all he does today is a bit of buddying and attacking the low-hanging fruit (PB, Mattimeo.) While I'd buy that Mattimeo could be scum because anyone could be scum when they're lurking as much as he is, his whole play just feels lazy. Which I would be if I were scum and the lead candidate was innocent and being lynched by villagers.
I've got some dirt on my shoulder, can you brush it off for me?