(May 2nd, 2013, 16:46)uberfish Wrote: Maybe I should post "if I was scum I'd have killed Zakalwe night 1" 10 times with slightly different wording too?
I was actually about to comment on that, as I was a little surprised to see you pull the exact same defense as Gaspar.
The irony is exceedingly delicious!
For me it really hinges on PB's claim. Without that, I would still be on Gaspar. But it's hard to find an explanation for his claim that makes more sense than "Uberfish is scum". And if I assume that Gaspar is innocent, it does make sense that you are scum, with the way you pushed him on day 2, as the most promising mislynch candidate. Bigger was really just treading water through all of day 2, which indicates that his buddy was under pressure. That fits with Gaspar, but it also fits with you.
It's also possible that PB is scum but it seems less likely. If he is, then he probably is a real jailer and jailed you while deliberately abstaining from the kill. I guess the plan would be to WIFOM his way out after your lynch. This sounds a little too fancy but who knows. If PB is scum then he's playing very well; on the other hand, Bigger made some pretty weak attacks on PB that might be interpreted as poor distancing attempts.
If neither you nor PB is scum then I'm still not seeing a very satisfactory answer to the lack of a death. Killing you to frame Gaspar and PB? I'm not buying that; it would do little to implicate them. The best I can come up with is if the last scum is an ability seer. Then either he scanned you, and considered you an extraordinary threat, or he scanned PB, and deliberately no-killed, in order to frame whoever PB targeted. As Gaspar would say, though, this requires a lot of moving parts.
If you know what I mean.