The day one silence was an active hindrance to scum-hunting, since it ended up with us lynching the path of least resistance. I thought it would end up with nothing but as it turned out, the little actual playing the game that occurred had us on the two scum so PB's vote analysis, which I would normally deride as premature, resulted in us basically being able to narrow the pool.
Today's silence is because the game is over. There is nothing left to discuss, at least from my end. There's nothing anyone could say that would get me to vote for anyone other than uberfish. That was true even before PB's claim for me - I still was completely convinced that was the next best course of action. The claim certainly lead pipe locks it, but regardless, I have nothing else to say.
PB's played an astonishingly good game for his first game in forever, though I suppose no surprise there. Lewwyn's played a very good game. I played a usual Gaspar game, which is just good enough. Mattimeo's been all over the place but made a key vote yesterday so get's a plus. Zak's been zak, but gets points for playing it straight enough on day one to convince me of his innocence. Otherwise the game might have devolved into zak vs Gaspar theatre even more than it did and probably would have given scum better room to hide. Serdoa and Ryan weren't around long enough to get a grade.
The scum had some bad luck, but at the end of the day I think the biggest mistake they made was letting the Ryan lynch sail through so easily. Anyway, these small games hinge on small decisions and this game certainly could have gone either way if Matt had stayed on me yesterday and PB couldn't block the kill as easily with 2 scum left. That would have probably left a zak, uber, Bigger, PB, Matt LyLo and I'd guess that Bigger and Uber could have gotten Mattimeo lynched for the win.
Was pretty fun outside of the vendetta but I definitely prefer larger games. Was interesting to see a game with such a high good player ratio though, not sure we've ever had one this high before.
I probably won't post again before the deadline, though I'll try and read the thread in case PB does anything entertaining.
Today's silence is because the game is over. There is nothing left to discuss, at least from my end. There's nothing anyone could say that would get me to vote for anyone other than uberfish. That was true even before PB's claim for me - I still was completely convinced that was the next best course of action. The claim certainly lead pipe locks it, but regardless, I have nothing else to say.
PB's played an astonishingly good game for his first game in forever, though I suppose no surprise there. Lewwyn's played a very good game. I played a usual Gaspar game, which is just good enough. Mattimeo's been all over the place but made a key vote yesterday so get's a plus. Zak's been zak, but gets points for playing it straight enough on day one to convince me of his innocence. Otherwise the game might have devolved into zak vs Gaspar theatre even more than it did and probably would have given scum better room to hide. Serdoa and Ryan weren't around long enough to get a grade.
The scum had some bad luck, but at the end of the day I think the biggest mistake they made was letting the Ryan lynch sail through so easily. Anyway, these small games hinge on small decisions and this game certainly could have gone either way if Matt had stayed on me yesterday and PB couldn't block the kill as easily with 2 scum left. That would have probably left a zak, uber, Bigger, PB, Matt LyLo and I'd guess that Bigger and Uber could have gotten Mattimeo lynched for the win.
Was pretty fun outside of the vendetta but I definitely prefer larger games. Was interesting to see a game with such a high good player ratio though, not sure we've ever had one this high before.
I probably won't post again before the deadline, though I'll try and read the thread in case PB does anything entertaining.
I've got some dirt on my shoulder, can you brush it off for me?