(December 18th, 2013, 17:26)Cyneheard Wrote: Per that randomization, Dtay is first,
I'm good with this order, but it's really better if someone not in the game makes these decisions. There are other, equally valid possible ways to resolve it. E.g. you can interpret the list as determining who's first in pick order (since that is what Sian said it was for!) - in that case dtay plays last. Or you could say the result is just invalid, because it uses a different process from what we needed and Sian didn't provide a fix himself, so we should roll again. It ends up being faster to wait for a lurker to unilaterally decide, than to propose a reasonable conclusion as a player and have all other players sign off on it.
Anyway, I suggest we go with whatever BRick says.