I decided to move the warrior, so that we have more information to decide where to settle. Since no objected, I took that everyone agreed with my suggested move. 
Settling where the warrior is is pretty good. Hill tile, starts working a deer from the get go (which goes to 4 food with granary and camp), has marble for the wonder bonus + another luxury (and a thrd one in 3rd ring). The Capital would need quite a bit culture expansions to get the river tiles for farming later, but going Tradition solves that (I think the borders would go -> marble -> grassriver tiles.
For those not used to BNW, there's no more gold bonus on river tiles, the only advantage of river is for irrigation, watermill, garden and some TR bonus that I don't know how it works/if it matters much or at all.
I wouldn't mind doing T-hawk suggested moves with the settler, either. 1NW with the settler + settling on dyes could work, but it's a bit of a gamble for a food resource in the fog. Otherwise, we lose the faith bonus and get nothing in return, other than a better city tile. Keep going N with the settler could also work (NW, NE gains marble and I really doubt there's no food up there -> famous last words).
Ah, holy warriors is a Follower belief, so if we lose it, we can still get units by adopting the religion of whoever took it. Not exactly sure about how to do that in practice, but we could.
Settling where the warrior is is pretty good. Hill tile, starts working a deer from the get go (which goes to 4 food with granary and camp), has marble for the wonder bonus + another luxury (and a thrd one in 3rd ring). The Capital would need quite a bit culture expansions to get the river tiles for farming later, but going Tradition solves that (I think the borders would go -> marble -> grassriver tiles.
For those not used to BNW, there's no more gold bonus on river tiles, the only advantage of river is for irrigation, watermill, garden and some TR bonus that I don't know how it works/if it matters much or at all.
I wouldn't mind doing T-hawk suggested moves with the settler, either. 1NW with the settler + settling on dyes could work, but it's a bit of a gamble for a food resource in the fog. Otherwise, we lose the faith bonus and get nothing in return, other than a better city tile. Keep going N with the settler could also work (NW, NE gains marble and I really doubt there's no food up there -> famous last words).
Ah, holy warriors is a Follower belief, so if we lose it, we can still get units by adopting the religion of whoever took it. Not exactly sure about how to do that in practice, but we could.