I was in a game when something like this happened. 
Psillycyber has to die now.
That other person also has to die because if he's scum you ****ed the town by not doing anything. So he would get metacleared. What we did was killed both but not allow scum to nightkill.
If he really is scum you are ****ing the town by letting him live so I would just kill both then and let scum keep their nightkill.

Psillycyber has to die now.
That other person also has to die because if he's scum you ****ed the town by not doing anything. So he would get metacleared. What we did was killed both but not allow scum to nightkill.
If he really is scum you are ****ing the town by letting him live so I would just kill both then and let scum keep their nightkill.