WW16: The Outlaws and The Olives

[Jkaen]

Because the stupidity of saying a villager novice would fake it does rub me wrong on every nerve. And I do try to find out if those saying it are a)villagers and really that ..... or b) wolves trying to throw as much dirt as possible on novice.

You need to learn to step back sometimes from your tunnel vision crusades.

Lots of people are saying that village novice COULD fake it. Nobody is saying he did.

And you now have at least Tansuke, Bigger, Selrahc, Me, and probably half the rest of the game that say that yes it is possible.

You however seem to be ignoring the fact that we are all (maybe not Tansuke) saying that we dont think he did though!

[Catwalk]

I don't think Rowain is saying novice wouldn't fake it, he's saying it's highly implausible. This stands in contrast to Bigger who says it's plausible he'd fake it, EVEN as a villager. I don't see this as tunnel vision from Rowain.

Serdoa, I'm done talking to you. You're either deliberately aggravating me or just being a [censored], either way you're a waste of time. I clicked preview post a few seconds before posting my request for a tally (maybe as much as 10), you submitted yours within those seconds. So kindly STFU.

[uberfish]

This argument about whether village novice might have faked a post restriction or not is useless noise that doesn't say anything about anyone's alignment. Just wait and see who, if anyone, gets post restricted tomorrow.

[Rowain]

And you now have at least Tansuke, Bigger, Selrahc, Me, and probably half the rest of the game that say that yes it is possible.

That you Bigger and Tasunke ay so is no surprise as you fall clearly under section a. Selrahc on the other hand.

[Selrahc]

I think it's unlikely. I just don't think it's impossible.

[Qgqqqqq]

Caught up.

I don't like this one bit. You're around to post a vote that you 'want to count' - yet just throw it out there as you admit you 'haven't caught up'.

That's not good

I was around for 5 f-ing minutes, and the forum wasted my original. I had slept in b/c i stayed up playing ww, and was late for a meeting.
Really TT do you want my life story?!?
I havent lurked much here, and you have a record for this, but that was a VERY stupid post.
Pity about sareln (GG btw)

[Qgqqqqq]

but prehaps inevitable with the split votes today.

novice i know this is a big ask, but could you take ts through your arguments and top suspects?
While you did a great job, Im sure stuff was lost in translation.

[waterbat]

Waterbat - can you repost that skimmer? And anything I need to know about how it works, I've not played with you since you rolled that out. I want to check out a hunch and I think the tool would save me some legwork.

its at http://www.cassidyweb.com/ww16

also might be of use to Tasunke who was using the forum's search for the same.

I've updated it to cover the first 1200 posts.

instructions for use:
don't click-spam it
be patient

each time you click something , it pulls in all 1200 posts. you'll see some repeats at the end until we hit 1200.

[novice]

its at http://www.cassidyweb.com/ww16

also might be of use to Tasunke who was using the forum's search for the same.

I've updated it to cover the first 1200 posts.

instructions for use:
don't click-spam it
be patient

each time you click something , it pulls in all 1200 posts. you'll see some repeats at the end until we hit 1200.

Maybe you could just script it to generate one static html for each player and link us to those?

[waterbat]

Pindicator, you were voting Ichabod. I said the score was 7.1 (you) 6 (icha) and 5 (sareln). Then you say "If its that close, ill vote sareln". So then the score became 7.1 - 5 - 6. Nothing really changed for you. Why the change?

If I were scum and knew A was guilty and B innocent up for lynch - I can't vote A because then he hangs. And I can't vote B because then I'm voting for an innocent and saving a scum, which later will look bad on my report card. So seeking safety by voting X is to me a scummy move. At least if the person is there for the lynch.

this was my reasoning exactly for wanting to do a late switch to pindicator (off of uber), but i just didn't have any clue as to the exact count - was picking between pindicator and sareln - also didnt realize ichabod was up so high.

With the vote split approximately 1/3 each way and still 5 NAPpers out there - it is not surprising that we didn't hit one of them - it was too close at the end to not be manipulated. we should be able to mine some good data there