WW16: The Outlaws and The Olives

[uberfish]

Well that's really annoying. I think this means wolves do have a post restrictor. Absolutely no town reason to target Meiz, who was under some suspicion for lurking, to silence him. Does not clear Novice or Meiz of being wolves faking one of the post restrictions though.

This sucks. Scum get watcher and an OP post restrictor. town gets lovers (yay) and allegedly a 3-shot doctor? we'd better have something very strong in those last 3 PR slots...

[Meiz]

thestick =
Serdoa =

Fork
Lobster

[uberfish]

Meiz, how about you just post Fork for yes/agree, Lobster for no/disagree and Banana for WTF

also please answer with a vote list:

1) Who do you think is suspicious for day 1 voting?
2) Who do you think is suspicious for day 2 voting?

[Meiz]

@uberfish, Fork

[Rowain]

If you thought Ichabod was a good lynch why did you never state that? You were on me most of the day and never shook off. (Or did you and I missed it?)

I was o nthe one I thought the very best lynch : You.

Piggyback's novice on day one.



Passive defense of thestick.

That was all that really stuod out on day 1 - generally he sounded Rowain-ish except the novice thing, which is not his style. As a general rule, he tends to run contrarian to whatever Novice/Zak do. Day 2 on the other hand...

Not going to paste, but he starts out night 2 on posts 406, 408 and 412 attempting to discredit novice. I don't think questioning anyone is bad play, but to my ears he was not questioning him (village move) but rather trying to attack his credibility (scum move.) After zak dies and day 2 starts, he goes right back to friends with novice in posts 504 & 540 in what I read as a "ok novice is on wrong track, I can get behind this" kind of tone.

So scoring at home, 2 days, 2 piggybacks of novice with a mild attempt to discredit him in between. Then he swapped to pindicator and never left, but more importantly...

Then it really starts, what sort of drew my attention to him here:



In the spoiler is 9 solid posts where he's asking about other people's reads and sharing none of his own. I generally believe this as scummy play - scum LOVES finding out everyone else's reads without sharing their own, because it allows them to gauge where they are in the "ranking" and adjust their play accordingly. Nothing wrong with asking for some contribution from folks here and there to clarify a read, but spamming up the thread with it while saying nothing yourself... scummy.

And... really that's all of day 2. There's another dozen similar posts. I've looked through Waterbats skimmer like 15 times and everytime its "Hey so and so, what do you think about this?" without once ever really explaining how he feels about anything.

Anyone doubting, go look for yourselves. Just one post after another quizzing people without suggesting so much as a single original thought.

So hey Rowain, why don't you tell us how you feel about the game before you play 20 questions with everyone else again?

Are you lyiungon purpose or were you just too lazy to really read my posts / the psts I reacted too or do you just have difficulties to understand some parts??

day1: I did not piggyback novice because novice did not vote Bigger. And if you manage somehow to reaad the votes on day 1 you will see that I stayed on Bigger while novice voted and stayed on thestick. If that is piggybacking for you then I think everybody is piggybacking everryone here.

day2: After the discussion during the night with novice I was convinced that he is village (you can see that believe also in my discussion last night). So I joined him on Qg and questioed Qg. After Qg had answered so far to my satisfaction I voted pindicator. If yo0u happen to read through you see that I do think pindis action weird already duriong the night , I did it again during the day and I placed my vote on him and tried toi get him lynched. So I absolutly don't see where you come with your 'why don't you tell us what you think-shit'. BTW Sareln used mostly the same things I had already posted to make his post. I was on my preferred target for which I have given reasons but I did try to get insights into other players thats why I ask question.

D3: Selrahc Reason: His post were he gives motives why a villager novice would fake a PR.

[uberfish]

Also Meiz are you allowed to quote posts (guessing no...)

[Meiz]

Lobster

[Azza]

The mafia wouldn't have had a chance to have spied on Bigger/Serdoa before thestick died, would they?

[Mattimeo]

thestick, the Mailman, was killed day 1. He was a Spy for the mafia.

Spy - You are the slickest of turncoats, always gathering information. Once per night choose a target, you will learn the identities of every person that visits your target that night, if any visits occur.

I don't think thestick would have been capable of identifying that Bigger/Serdoa were lovers...

[Catwalk]

Meiz, can you use symbols? If so, that can easily be turned into a number code.
! = 1
" = 2
# = 3

And so on, you can use that to refer to post numbers.