WW 19 Game Thread - Mobster Mayhem - GAME OVER

[pindicator]

I guess I am dense then, because i don't see how that retort is logical at all. Different people see different things, that's part of the game! Hell, that IS the game. So you using Lewwyn's words and mine like they came from the same train of thought is entirely insincere and shows no desire to address either of our accusations.

Offer still stands btw- you can use yournext post to continue this argument or you can use it to show you want to hunt scum.

And at waterbat

[pindicator]

Waterbat . who did u give the gas can to.

That's an awful question
We don't want scum to know that

[Ryan]

We want the vigi to know that.

[Ryan]

and BTW, I think I am learning and improving for my first game but whatever. Your still butt hurt over my attacks on you :P *waterbat*

[Serdoa]

Actually no, we don't want the vigi to know that. We want him to make a decision based on who is most likely scum, not who has the gas can. The gas can is NOT telling anything about the alignment of the player and I'd rather have the vig die and take out a gas-can-scum with it as making the gas-can worthless. Thats why I didn't ask waterbat, after it was clear that we could not use it to clear him.

I haven't him forgotten either, but I believe that right now, we need to lynch Selrahc. He is not getting pushed enough for how he plays imo and that makes me wary. Scum should love the opportunity to jump on him for all his meta-stuff but nothing happens. Maybe because he is scum. Either way, I think we can learn something by lynching him and analyzing afterwards.

[Ryan]

Selrahc Unless we get a pretty good claim..Azza can wait.

[uberfish]

so:

Azza attacks ryan.

Selrahc #1373: brings up the Bigger PM as a reason to be suspicious of Ryan

No one else jumps on ryan. I disagree with selrahc's position

Selrahc #1402: decides that the bigger PM is now more likely a sign that ryan is village

I think Selrahc was fishing for a Ryan bandwagon here, and backtracked later after no one else was buying it.

[Ryan]

and guys im suiciding from the game.

[zakalwe]

I guess I am dense then, because i don't see how that retort is logical at all. Different people see different things, that's part of the game! Hell, that IS the game. So you using Lewwyn's words and mine like they came from the same train of thought is entirely insincere and shows no desire to address either of our accusations.

Offer still stands btw- you can use yournext post to continue this argument or you can use it to show you want to hunt scum.

And at waterbat

Say what? I have no desire to address your accusations? Give me a FUCKING break. What the hell do you think I've been doing all day? Has it occurred to you that if you want me to scum hunt, then MAYBE the best way to encourage that isn't to bombard me with stupid tone reading accusations that are impossible to defend against, yet put me in real danger of being lynched, so I have to try?

You and Lewwyn are ganging up on me, and I try to address all of the accusations that are directed at me. From MY point of view it is ironic that the arguments against me contradict each other. If you disagree with parts of Lewwyn's arguments, then you are free to state so. But you've been his fanboy all along and embrace everything he says. So yeah, THAT is hypocrisy, given that your arguments don't jibe with his. You'll just have to pardon me if I didn't distinguish properly between one pile of bad arguments and the other.

And by the way, my next post after that one was in fact a question to you about Mattimeo, which you promptly ignored. How can you seriously think that I am the best lynch today? With all the blatant lurking going on, that's just ludicrous.

I haven't him forgotten either, but I believe that right now, we need to lynch Selrahc. He is not getting pushed enough for how he plays imo and that makes me wary. Scum should love the opportunity to jump on him for all his meta-stuff but nothing happens. Maybe because he is scum. Either way, I think we can learn something by lynching him and analyzing afterwards.

I tend to agree with this. Since I can't gain any traction on Lewwyn, I'll join you on Selrahc. Let's see how he flips, so we know what happened yesterday, and can move on.

[Selrahc]

Selrahc #1402: decides that the bigger PM is now more likely a sign that ryan is village

Is that what you think I was saying? In fact I thought I said the opposite. That the bigger pm was not a scum slip but was a possibility for an intentional deception.

What I added on was that everything apart from the PM didn't really feel right for a deception though. Which, um, I did sort of say originally? That the one thing that was worrying me was the bigger PM?