We were way too obvious really. The two sides were clearly separated, my only regret now is not being more obvious. If I had just stepped out and given the whole layout away Fenn would have voted for Jabbz and with Matt's help we would have won.
This is a message I spent a very long time writing yesterday night and ended up not sending. I would have sent it but for an obvious flaw in the reasoning, and I still believed we had a chance to confuse Jabbz playing normally.
Let's look at the possibilities, assuming there are three bad guys as some people have been supposing :
I'm a minion. If this stays this way I'm bussed and I win.
I'm a wolf. The wolf team could vote for the tanner just for kicks so town doesn't necessarily win. Means I'm lying.
I'm a tanner. I'm on my way to winning. Means Fenn was lying.
I'm town. Have I been keeping a big surprise for the all-too-happy wolves all this time ?
Turns out I have. I'm the seer. I looked at Mattimeo and he is a minion. At least one of Lewwyn TT or Jabbz is lying. The obvious answer is that TT is the lone wolf who saw the troublemaker card in the center. Lewwyn is possible but unlikely and Jabbz is very unlikely because of the Lewwyn confirmation. I'm going to go with the obvious here, it worked well last game.
Coming to why I played this game that way. I made an honest mistake about the setting, and Lewwyn directly jumped at me. I decided to keep my claim for later, to see where this was going. I'd claim minion, try to find out who was who without too much pressure, then take out the obvious liar. As many noticed it was an odd reveal, which was also in my advantage. The only way that wouldn't work is if Matt decided to bust me, but why would he ? I could have doppled him, he couldn't know. And there was always a problem for the wolves : I could be the tanner. That's probably why Matt hasn't voted for me, he's still unsure. And that's why I didn't mind making my reveal sound odd, I was supposed to be potentially a tanner impersonating a minion. While I was really a seer impersonating a tanner impersonating a minion
This way I come to you with a certainty : Matt is minion, TT is lone wolf. Fenn was either tanner at the start or he doppled Matt, and probably the opposite is true for Rowain (whatever Fenn's not).
Why didn't I come out earlier ? Because for all my patience I wasn't sure who the wolf was. For a time I thought it was Fenn but I'm now completely certain that it's TT : he was on Fenn for sure just a few hours ago, and now that Lewwyn makes a case against me he's turning around and changing his vote. He just want someone to hang so he'll go with whoever's not him or Fenn. And yes he did vote for self proclaimed tanner Fenn earlier, what a good way to clear his name. He's now officially a good guy in Lewwyn's mind. And guess who's not getting any votes any more ? Fenn.
So let's take out the wolf guys : TT
This is a message I spent a very long time writing yesterday night and ended up not sending. I would have sent it but for an obvious flaw in the reasoning, and I still believed we had a chance to confuse Jabbz playing normally.
Let's look at the possibilities, assuming there are three bad guys as some people have been supposing :
I'm a minion. If this stays this way I'm bussed and I win.
I'm a wolf. The wolf team could vote for the tanner just for kicks so town doesn't necessarily win. Means I'm lying.
I'm a tanner. I'm on my way to winning. Means Fenn was lying.
I'm town. Have I been keeping a big surprise for the all-too-happy wolves all this time ?
Turns out I have. I'm the seer. I looked at Mattimeo and he is a minion. At least one of Lewwyn TT or Jabbz is lying. The obvious answer is that TT is the lone wolf who saw the troublemaker card in the center. Lewwyn is possible but unlikely and Jabbz is very unlikely because of the Lewwyn confirmation. I'm going to go with the obvious here, it worked well last game.
Coming to why I played this game that way. I made an honest mistake about the setting, and Lewwyn directly jumped at me. I decided to keep my claim for later, to see where this was going. I'd claim minion, try to find out who was who without too much pressure, then take out the obvious liar. As many noticed it was an odd reveal, which was also in my advantage. The only way that wouldn't work is if Matt decided to bust me, but why would he ? I could have doppled him, he couldn't know. And there was always a problem for the wolves : I could be the tanner. That's probably why Matt hasn't voted for me, he's still unsure. And that's why I didn't mind making my reveal sound odd, I was supposed to be potentially a tanner impersonating a minion. While I was really a seer impersonating a tanner impersonating a minion
This way I come to you with a certainty : Matt is minion, TT is lone wolf. Fenn was either tanner at the start or he doppled Matt, and probably the opposite is true for Rowain (whatever Fenn's not).
Why didn't I come out earlier ? Because for all my patience I wasn't sure who the wolf was. For a time I thought it was Fenn but I'm now completely certain that it's TT : he was on Fenn for sure just a few hours ago, and now that Lewwyn makes a case against me he's turning around and changing his vote. He just want someone to hang so he'll go with whoever's not him or Fenn. And yes he did vote for self proclaimed tanner Fenn earlier, what a good way to clear his name. He's now officially a good guy in Lewwyn's mind. And guess who's not getting any votes any more ? Fenn.
So let's take out the wolf guys : TT
