[Lurkers]WW 38: Judging a Player by his Cover

[Jowy]

WP Pindicator. Never got caught either. Sooo close to a win!

[pindicator]

LOL - there really is a third party!

Or is there?

[Qgqqqqq]

Yeah, well played Pindicater. You did good, and the lynchwagons had pretty much swung away from you by the end, at least from my reading.

[Gustaran]

Frankly, I don't care. This game was ruined by unfair play. Asking for modkills is totally against the rules and, as fas as I'm concerned, everyone already lost. I'm disappointed and this game was not fun at all.

He's got a point there, I wonder why this dumb asking for modkills is even accepted? I could understand in the case of an important real life problem beyond a player's control, but as a GM I would just ban players from future games who ask for being modkilled.

[Jowy]

There's no need to ban a newbie for that. He'll know next game not to do it.

[Gazglum]

Mattimeo a vengeful neighbour (plus one shot killer? What?). So I guess it's possible that Pindi killed Matt, was killed in return, and Gore was lovers with Matt because of his visit?

[Meiz]

I'm very glad you were scum and not town, Pind Well played.

[BRickAstley]

Mattimeo a vengeful neighbour (plus one shot killer? What?). So I guess it's possible that Pindi killed Matt, was killed in return, and Gore was lovers with Matt because of his visit?

Not quite.

[pindicator]

Thanks Meiz! Hope that day wasn't too stressful. I had to get rid of you, both for your power and for how zeroed in you were on me

Potential Spoiler:

I exchanged myself and Pindicator

Dang it AdrienIer, I told you not to swap yourself with towny people for a reason!

Wait a minute... does this mean...?

[MJW (ya that one)]

Frankly, I don't care. This game was ruined by unfair play. Asking for modkills is totally against the rules and, as fas as I'm concerned, everyone already lost. I'm disappointed and this game was not fun at all.

He's got a point there, I wonder why this dumb asking for modkills is even accepted? I could understand in the case of an important real life problem beyond a player's control, but as a GM I would just ban players from future games who ask for being modkilled.

I think this is a major overreaction because both players would have gotten lynched anyway. It's a good thing for everyone for someone to "resign" when there's no-way that they are going to live. I think Ichabod is just BSing it and trying to act like what a town Ichabod would do. There's a good chance I would vote for him just for that.

Now if someone uses suicide to gain a tactical edge then we have a problem but that didn't happen here.