Crescent Moon vs Eschuta's Temper on a Lightning Sorceress
A good Eschuta's Temper can be expensive although it is not extremely rare; the wide range of attributes on it can make a possible uber item a piece of junk. It ranges from +1 to +3 Skills and +10 to +20% dmg. A Crescent Moon is a cheap runeword made of Shael Um Tir, on a Crystal Sword (To save stat points. Funny that, as if she needed to do that. 255 points saved
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ef0b9/ef0b9e7f5c8c969372fa208f49e9b35fde88ab11" alt="smoke smoke"
I let her use more points on Energy because a Lightning sorc is Mana hungry)
I have tested Eschuta's Temper against a +6 Enchant Leaf for a Fire sorceress and the Eschuta's came out ahead.
I am in the process of gearing up McTyraelGirl (not McTyraelGal, the purple girl who is the rich aunty who supplies all) for some farming. A little break from the Variants. I don't think I have talked about her before. She is a one trick pony Lightning sorc, not much to talk about. However, the question came up on the weapon of choice, Crescent Moon vs Eschuta's Temper. The following screens shows the stats from each setup
Clearly, The Eschuta's Temper does a lot more damage than the Crescent Moon on screen. 35K certainly sounds you have a bigger you know what than 29K. Most people would go for the 39K for bragging rights. However, the Crescent Moon's hidden power comes not from Slvl nor on screen damage. Its power, as far as Lightning damage is concerned, comes from the -35% Enemy Lightning Resistance. So what is that worth in RL? Simple math would suggest 29K x 1.35 = 39K
I could have over simplified all that's involved, i.e. garbage in garbage out. Seems like Crescent Moon wins. It would also hold true in some quick play test using Nova (less random dmg) vs some quick access Hell Act5 monsters when the spell levels were lower. Crescent Moon seems to have a slight advantage as the simple math suggested - Maybe 5 casts vs Eschuta's 5-6 casts.
The Difference:
- The tests were done on slow mode so that I can keep tab on the casts. Casting speed would make a difference in actual play.
- Crescent Moon's 2 Mana after Each Kill a definite plus for a Mana hungry build.
- Eschuta's Temper faster cast easily takes Teleport into the next FCR so she feels good at zipping around.
- Lightning and Chain Lightning use a different FCR calculation. There is only a break point (20% more to 2 break points via Magefist instead of Frostburn) difference between the two weapons with McTyraelGirl's current setup.
Overkill - She is probably going to hit +40K when she's fully equipped. How much is enough? ... not to mention, cough, her merc holds an Infinity, cough...
Although Crescent Moon is the more damaging weapon, and the +2 Mana after each kill is helpful, I think I might end up using the Eschuta's because it FEELS faster...
PS: Still room to improve the Eschuta's with a Jewel
.