WW16: The Outlaws and The Olives

[pindicator]

The second quote jumped out at me in my reread, "Hey, list your suspicions so I can follow up on the villager ones."

Yeah, I can see it a bit in there too. It lacked the comedic timing with the last pair of quotes, though

[waterbat]

Lewwyn* and Qgqqqqq,

what about day3 when catwalk stayed in the lead until the very end when we (myself included) called for Mero to hang (and Mero subsequently claimed himself to death)?

Assuming that was the villager-led misstep it appeared to be, doesn't that make you think that catwalk is innocent? The mafia were just going to let catwalk go without a fight? Unless they came out in force in that last little Mero push, i don't see it.

Hmmm... Indeed, it may be worth it to lynch catwalk forthwith to get the information it gives. If mafioso, we certainly get some suspects in the Mero push. If villager, i think late Merovech movers get some cred there as it would seem an unnecessary risk for the mafia to move votes from villager to villager at such a late stage.

* = typed it without having to correct it that time (very rare)

Not sure what I did to get on your scumdar, Lewwyn - but I'm sure you will let me know soon. If it is tied to the catwalk-mero thing, well, not sure what to say. I hope we hit a guilty party and if doing so makes me look incredibly bad, so be it.

catwalk

[waterbat]

re-reading my post, im thinking "WHY am I considering lynching for info? Don't we have enough to go on at this point to vote for scum directly?"

[waterbat]

Why would you want to lynch Arromir if he doesn't get mod-killed?

Missed this question before. If he doesnt get mod-killed, we'd have to do it eventually, right?

If I pulled wolf though, I wouldnt disengage from the game. I'd do whatever I could to stay in it. But... who knows what happened.

[Qgqqqqq]

WTF injera, I was trying to get an explanation for his actions (which we didnt have as he was PR.
He wouldnt have been telling us anything new so i didnt need that if id wanted to follow i already had all i needed (as cw showed).

Also pindi do yknow theres a difference between trying to lynch someone and asking a question?!?

[pindicator]

re-reading my post, im thinking "WHY am I considering lynching for info? Don't we have enough to go on at this point to vote for scum directly?"

What kind of info would a catwalk lynch bring you?

[Meiz]

Well, willing to give Matt & Injera more time, in case they can somehow confirm each other.

Gonna vote Selrahc. I know he is limited to phone access, but so was I and it wasn't that hard to contribute. Of course any major vote analyses etc. are not really possible, but I think his play so far has been worse than can be explained with the limited access.

Votes Qgqq, http://realmsbeyond.net/forums/showpost....tcount=584
But at the same time encourages Sareln train, http://realmsbeyond.net/forums/showpost....tcount=621
http://realmsbeyond.net/forums/showpost....tcount=629
"But a Sareln lynch might be valauable as a corroboraating or refuting point..."

Votes Catwalk, http://realmsbeyond.net/forums/showpost....count=1500
But then unvotes, http://realmsbeyond.net/forums/showpost....count=1527
"I'm not really comfortable having semi-informed opinions affecting a possibly marginal vote. I find Catwalk most suspicious, but I'll leave the vote for it off."

Makes me think he wants to stay away from lynch wagons by purpose, to cover his trails...

[Catwalk]

Lewwyn, I was stating that Injera's claim was a good one if there was a decent chance of busting Mattimeo. I found it worthwhile for Injera to out himself if it led to a certain lynch. Sadly, Injera only tracked Mattimeo once. I have no idea why, since Mattimeo was the only PR we knew and one whose claim was being doubted. Any particular reason you didn't stay on him Injera? None of that is WTF material IMO.

waterbat, you think I'm innocent and want to lynch me to make sure?

I agree with the vote on Qg, in absence of a smoking gun on Mattimeo. I still think Mattimeo is guilty, but if we can test him that's preferrable. On that note, was it Injera who said earlier that Mattimeo's claim could be tested? Can't find the post.

[Meiz]

Makes me think he wants to stay away from lynch wagons by purpose, to cover his trails...

To add to this, he is now voting Qgqq, but his vote was the second.

[novice]

was it Injera who said earlier that Mattimeo's claim could be tested? Can't find the post.

Sareln said Thestick's claim could be tested, don't know if that's what you're thinking of.

Do you legitimately suspect Qg or is this "anyone but catwalk"?

I suspect him for the same reasons I suspected him day 2, and Molach also points out problems with his style.

Targets:
Night 1: myself
Night 2: no-one
Night 3: no-one

This is just terrible. Why would you not use your charges? It was even pointed out to you that you should use them since your life expectancy would be quite short (by catwalk, I believe).

(in before "of course you would claim to have not targetted anyone if you were lying and Injera had given away the information he has")

I'll say it anyway. Very convenient claim by you given that

any combination of self-use or no action would have produced the same results

If you're wanting actual confirmation... I still have two shots. I can garuntee I'll use one tonight, if you like.

Yes please. And frankly I think you should NOT target yourself. If the wolves kill you, so be it, we were going to lynch you anyway. If you save yourself, we won't be able to distinguish that from a deliberate no-kill. So the only way you can prove your innocense is by dying or by being tracked saving someone else.