WW16: The Outlaws and The Olives

[Meiz]

Catwalk, Injera said he followed you on night 3 and you did nothing. Is he telling the truth? If so, doesn't that make you think he might be telling the truth of his role? What are the chances that wolves had tracker and watcher? Not likely, I think...

It bothers me that Selrahc has been online but hasn't reacted to the votes. You'd think villager would fight back. Does he trust that he will not be lynched, as wolves have a lot of voting power? Votes haven't moved away from Qgqq at all...

[pindicator]

Ichabod - I got a lot of scum reads off his latest stuff.

Like the post I just quoted and asked him to respond to. His vote was on catwalk, merovech does his claim, and qgqqqqq's post is to say "i don't believe merovech, but come on catwalk there's still time to defend!" - and he doesn't change his vote off catwalk? it's like he's trying to have it both ways

Then at night, after lewwyn blew up, asks who lewwyn is upset at, and I got the feeling like he was trying to target someone - but lewwyn didn't name a name so he lost interest.

Today I he chastised catwalk for attacking a power role while subsequently attacking a power role.


But

When I look at his earlier stuff, like in day 2, he looks pretty village. So right now I'm pretty confused, which was why I wanted to hear him explain the post at the end of the day yesterday.

[Ichabod]

Selrahc.

Still want to hear the thoughts about Qgqqqq from the people voting for him.

[Ichabod]

Ichabod - I got a lot of scum reads off his latest stuff.

Like the post I just quoted and asked him to respond to. His vote was on catwalk, merovech does his claim, and qgqqqqq's post is to say "i don't believe merovech, but come on catwalk there's still time to defend!" - and he doesn't change his vote off catwalk? it's like he's trying to have it both ways

Then at night, after lewwyn blew up, asks who lewwyn is upset at, and I got the feeling like he was trying to target someone - but lewwyn didn't name a name so he lost interest.

Today I he chastised catwalk for attacking a power role while subsequently attacking a power role.


But

When I look at his earlier stuff, like in day 2, he looks pretty village. So right now I'm pretty confused, which was why I wanted to hear him explain the post at the end of the day yesterday.

Thanks.

Still want to hear from other people too.

[BRickAstley]

Official Lynch Vote Count

Qgqqqqq - 7 - Molach, Selrahc, Pindicator, Catwalk, tasunke, Gaspar, Waterbat
Selrahc - 5 - Meiz, Jkaen, novice, Lewwyn, Ichabod
Catwalk - 3 - Injera, Azza, Qgqqqqq
Mattimeo - 1 - Twinkletoes89
Twinkletoes89 - 1 - Mattimeo

Players not voting: Arromir, Rowain

[Twinkletoes89]

One day you'll listen and it will be too late

[Ichabod]

One day you'll listen and it will be too late

I'm feeling very similar to you, TT, but, right now, lynching either Matt or Injera isn't possible. So, don't throw your vote away and pick another target. It doesn't have to be Selrahc or Qgqqqqq, but your best guesses aren't going to be voted right now.

We still have time to discuss. Giving up now won't help us, though.

[Meiz]

TT, do you think Injera is a wolf, or what makes you so certain that the test will fail?

I do agree that lynching Selrahc is a bit of a coinflip. If he flips blue/red, there's not much trail left in any case. But I strongly believe the trail is that non-existant by purpose.

[Ichabod]

Aren't you going to vote, Rowain?

By the way, is it just me or Rowain has been way more silent ever since he stopped being voted?

And regarding this post:

Part2

Befoer a short comment as I saw just novices post with the votes: Overdone vote-alyzing was what did cost the village WW14.
Nevertheless to continue: Day 1:
5 hours before lynch thestick is in the lead with 4 votes.
Then the Mattimeo-BW starts to run started by Serdoa (villager) comment he would vote Mattimeo do note that he votes thestick with that post. followed by uberfish(villager) that he would vote Mattimeo over thestick.

Then followed the first real vote: from pindicator then Sareln,Serdoa,uberfish (all 3 vill) and lastly TT.

Now we have 3 possiblities: a) Mattimeo is a fraud and we really had 2 wolves under the 3 topsuspects.
b) Mattimeo is real and pindicator used the comments from uber and Serdoa to make a run to save thestick. His later actions do support that (unvote, thestick, move to Merovech)
c) pindi is a villager but Matt is too are we really to believe that wolves sat on their hands happily lynching thestick? If no then of course TT is a wolf.

So to answer your question novice:
Yes pind is still high on my list: I would also be ok with a Tasunke and TT-lynch. Ichabod and Azza are currently second tier for me. And Mattimeo is a special case.

I find it not very Rowain-style to not have any of the "big names" in his suspect list. There's no gaspar, no novice, no Lewwyn... Does this make any sense to others?

Still want some answers to my Qgqqqq question. Sorry to be talking a lot, but I'm not feeling so well about our current lynch movement.

[novice]

I don't understand how the test makes any sense:
1) Mattimeo may be scum with a cloaker ability (either working as stated or working differently)
2) They may both be scum
3) If Mattimeo is scum and Injera is innocent, scum can eat Injera at night (same can be done if Mattimeo is innocent to frame him)

How can we get any useful information out of this test?

3) is the reason Mattimeo should cloak Injera. If Mattimeo dies in the process because he is villager, so be it.

Ichabod, you spoke very strongly against a Mattimeo lynch, so strongly that you chased everyone away from voting him, and now you want to lynch him. What changed?