WW16: The Outlaws and The Olives

[novice]

So lets get the movements right we have :

Matt: Matt, Nobody, Nobody
Inj: Pind, Matt, CW
Qg: Matt, Novice, Inj (moved to CW)

So one of Qg and Matt is lying for sure

Why? I don't follow.

Anyway, why would the wolf watcher be called a Spy, and the village tracker be called a "Night Tracker" - it doesn't fit. Brick put effort into the flavour here, he would find a title for the tracker, "Tinkerer", for example.

Also Qgqqqqq's reaction to Injera's claim seems wrong.

Qgqqqqqq

[Qgqqqqq]

jkaen your wrong matts powe r means my tracking failed.
wont be bak till after lynch, good luck!

[pindicator]

Well, considering that:

1. Believing in Qgqqqq is believing there's a tracker in the village and one in the Mafia (how would Injera know about Mattimeo no result if not for that?)

2. I think a tracker role is very weak, so when Injera made his claim, I'd jump at that very moment to accuse him on his lie, especially since I'd know he's a mafia power role (due to doing something to Catwalk). Losing my power is well worth it to catch a Mafia, way more than I'd believe it can accomplish.

I'll vote for Qgqqqq.

#2 is a good point.

Qgqqqqq

[Qgqqqqq]

all i get is who they visit, NOT what they do.

[waterbat]

So if we believe the two roles would not coexist then we either have:

Inj & Matt lying, Qg truth
Qg Lying (other unknown)

So we lynch Qg, we either hit a wolf, or we reveal 2 wolves. Is there a fault with that logic?

bah! JKaen - your post actually got me thinking the first option is more likely.

if a) we had 2 wolves on the block day 1 (Matt + Stick) and b) the pressure resurfaces on Mattimeo, then wolf-Injera may indeed have been confident enough to fake a role claim like that to support Mattimeo and himself at the same time. We've had 6 villagers die in succession - I wouldn't put any crazy play like this past the mafia right now due to confidence high they must be on.

[Meiz]

jkaen your wrong matts powe r means my tracking failed.
wont be bak till after lynch, good luck!

It's like your typing 15 minutes behind...

You got failed result from matt and a different result from novice, or?

[Twinkletoes89]

Qgqqqqq, if you turn out innocent you really need to work on being a lot more convincing in your defence.

I just cannot believe your claims because you give me absolutely nothing that suggests you aren't lying.

[Injera]

You see what they do and you see their target or you only see what they do?

I don't know. It says I see what action(s) they took. It's ambiguous if that includes the target.

[pindicator]

I follow someone and see what they do, which is a tracker I think.

all i get is who they visit, NOT what they do.

Selrahc
I hate today

[Qgqqqqq]

no meiz i got same on both no result
yeah i keep x posting