WW 31 Game Thread PARANOIA

[spacetyrantxenu]

I also never received any word from Brick about being double charged.
Mattimeo

Wait, did Mattimeo lie about who he used his skill on previous nights?

Can anyone else confirm this?

[spacetyrantxenu]

my previous request for Mattimeo to contribute meaningfully to the discussion has largely been ignored, so my suspicion of him is growing.

I did say this before, just a bit ago -- if someone can confirm Mattimeo has been lying, that seems a more damning offense than Q (badly, IMO) misplaying his role.

[Jowy]

Something is certainly up with the missing double charges and his strange item use.

[Jowy]

Serdoa, Sunrise targeted me N4.

[Ichabod]

The problem I see about voting Mattimeo due to his role is: why wouldn't he use his role if he's scum? I think we are fairly certain that Mattimeo's role exist, since we have seen it being used on 2 different occasions.

Regarding Qgq, we could kind of test his claim, by making me and Jowy (useless roles) target a specific player on a night (the one we are most suspicious of being scum, in order to avoid a simple night kill from the scum as an obstacle for this test). Well, I and Jowy would choose to target that player or not, so Qgq would have to guess right 2 (or 1 time, if Jowy is a baddie together with Qgq, which seems unlikely - or if one os us is killed that night) times in order to not get caught up faking.

Not sure why that would be of much value, but at least it's of some value, which can't be said about my power and Jowy's. Did I say that my message power is limited to 160 characters? Yup, tough luck...

[spacetyrantxenu]

Do we have proof the items do anything? Has anyone who has used one so far been able to confirm that the item did something productive, or noticeable?

[Jowy]

If Matt is scum, his role is more than what he has let on. I don't know what to think of it, but something seems to be up.

[Ichabod]

Well, here's something. I think night 3 was the night where Catwalk triggered his first set of bombs, killing MJW (night 3 target due to powers), Zak and Novice (good players). That night Qgq was blocked by Merovech. I have a feeling that he was the one doing the kill for mafia that day...

Jowy's clone gift to Qgq was also a bit strange... Why give a clone to Qgq when Serdoa and, especially, MJW had only 1 clone...?

I don't know, I think Jowy and Qgq seem to be a good scum pair.

Either way, that's mostly just for posterity sake and hindsight bragging rights. I'm fairly sure we won't kill these 2 for these reasons.

[Serdoa]

Actually I find that point at least interesting enough that I will go through my tables and see if that would work out Ichabod. In any case, you pointed out something important that I did ignore, that being that catwalk could have setup bombs every night and that they either had been triggered every night instantly or he has had to trigger them latest on N3.

[Ichabod]

Actually I find that point at least interesting enough that I will go through my tables and see if that would work out Ichabod. In any case, you pointed out something important that I did ignore, that being that catwalk could have setup bombs every night and that they either had been triggered every night instantly or he has had to trigger them latest on N3.

I think it doesn't work due to the 2 kills on night 1. One of them has to be Catwalk's, I think. So, Catwalk probably just skipped night 2 (kills were from Gaz, scum and Azarius). And he blew two bombs on night 3, I guess...