WW 44: Battlestar Galactica

[Dp101]

I'm going to bed. I'm actually kind of against claiming, now. I feel scum got really bad luck in flipping two vanilla towns, and claiming is too harsh on them. But if we want it, I will certainly participate.

This is very anti-town. As much as I like fair setups, it doesn't feel right to deliberately play in a way that we feel is worse just because we might win.

[Jabbz]

It is anti town, but I highly doubt it's scum. Gazglum just REALLY likes a challenge evidently.

[Dp101]

Well right now I'd rather he didn't, I am now firmly on the side on mass roleclaims.

[Dp101]

Oops, wrote another on instead of of, sorry for the error.

[Qgqqqqq]

Day 2 Vote Count 1:

Jabbz (1) Lewwyn
Lewwyn (1) Gazglum

Not voting (3): Jabbz, novice, Dp101

[Lewwyn]

I haven't read anything beyond this post.

Welcome, Lewwyn, to the Dumb Inquisition.

Oh, and of course Winston's death - who benefits? Lewwyn was the top of his scummy list, and scum only have to get through one more day.

Seriously?

Winston was killed, Winston suspected Lewwyn, Lewwyn is scum.

That's your logic?

Of course it is, and it would be yours if the positions were reversed. Our Werewolf games are as predictable as Parliament in this regard - one side always says 'there is no meaning in the night kills' and the other side says there is, and the players will happily reverse their positions next go round.

Scum win this round if they get one townie to vote with them. SO if you are scum, you would definitely want to remove the guy it seems you will have least chance to sway.

Town Lewwyn should ask who else the kill might benefit,  or at least say, "Yes, it looks bad, so it is probably a setup by You, Scumglum, so you could launch with this". Not just laugh it off, as if logic stops being logic if you put question mark after it.

I'm just going to address this right here.

Apparently my response WAS appropriate since you already have all the answers Gaz! I thought it was ridiculous to debate and apparently YOU AGREE, but that doesn't stop you from trying to use this against me. And hey you're right! It does look like a setup. I thought that was obvious.


You want to know who benefits from Winston's death? YOU, novice and DP. None of you died. All of you voted for Adrien. If Scum had killed one of those 3 they would have drawn more attention to whoever was left. So they don't want to kill one of those 3. Who are their other options? Me, Jabbz or Winston! Do you really think Scum would kill me? After everyone has trouble deciding my alignment? Jabbz? Seems like if he's killed nobody really benefits so particularly the way that I apparently benefit. Winston? Mostly thought of as town and was after me on the final vote. I think its fairly obvious who scum chose.

But I thought this was obvious. Town Gaz would not have tried to come after me with such a terrible argument. And one he had apparently already figured out. Of course I laughed it off. In the next breath you accuse me of defending too much! Which is gazglum do I defend too much or too little?

[Lewwyn]

Sorry, I was wrong. I thought I could soldier through, but I just don't have enough time to play this. It started too soon. Way too fucking soon. I'm a day behind in my grading.

Gazglum for now. I have to eat lunch and get back to work. I will be back tomorrow during the last 5 hours for a little bit. But I honestly have to buckle down here, I've already blown one deadline.

[Dp101]

Please at least find the time to claim.

[Dp101]

Since I think someone will probably call me on my progression later, let me state for the record that in the Lew/Gaz interactions I am moderately pro-lew at this stage.

[Jabbz]

Really? I think Gaz is being his normal Towny Gazy self, and Lewwyn comes across very defensive. Kind of like someone else I know. Then again, I've not had nice thoughts about Lewwyn most of the game, so I suppose it's not surprising.