WW38: The Story of the Stories

[Lewwyn]

Isn't Shadeun's stating that he'll need more convincing on Meiz merely a report on the result of his evaluation? Or what was your point, Lewwyn?

That's sort of my point. I'm obviously not voting for him right now, but I'm wary. Go back through his posts. Almost every single one of them equivocates. "I don't know this person well enough", "this game is not as standard as I'd hoped so my reads on people I know are useless" or something to that effect. It's a recurring theme in his posts.

[Goreripper]

I find it interesting that Goreripper, Mattimeo and Lewwyn were just voting Meiz 1 hour ago and are now unified on Molach.

Wenches and lesser warriors find themselves easily overawed by my the charismatic heft of my bulging thews!

I am glad, Fish-egg Wayne! Even though I am an obvious innocent it did not feel right to not be under the wrathful gaze of your gimlet orbs of sight!

[Ichabod]

Adrien is probably mislynch material right there. It's easy to see he'll escalate soon to the top of the list. He has a very unique way of playing, so it's easy to see scuminess in it...

I'm just pointing out that he's very easy to lynch, because his play is very different. And usually when I see a "this guy is an easy lynch" train on day 1, it ends up badly.

I find those statements and Lewwyn agreeing with it strange. Adrien survived till the last day in WW 36 and got nightkilled in 35. So I fail to see how he has suddenly the title of easy mislynch.

Well, I was the SK in 35 and I felt like I could fake a case in Adrien anytime. I didn't lurk 36, so I don't know. In this game too, I see a lot of things to pick on his play, that'd find suspicious in others, but that I think are just based on a different playstyle. Either way, is easy to put it in phony glasses.

Posting this to say that I just tuned into the thread today. I still have work to do, so I'm not sure I can everything I have to before voting.

[Shadeun]

Isn't Shadeun's stating that he'll need more convincing on Meiz merely a report on the result of his evaluation? Or what was your point, Lewwyn?

That's sort of my point. I'm obviously not voting for him right now, but I'm wary. Go back through his posts. Almost every single one of them equivocates. "I don't know this person well enough", "this game is not as standard as I'd hoped so my reads on people I know are useless" or something to that effect. It's a recurring theme in his posts.

God forbid I don't have strong reads on Day 1 Lewwyn? Matt, yes me saying that was just the results of me getting the time at work to read Meiz's stuff and have a think about it.

[Shadeun]

Isn't Shadeun's stating that he'll need more convincing on Meiz merely a report on the result of his evaluation? Or what was your point, Lewwyn?

That's sort of my point. I'm obviously not voting for him right now, but I'm wary. Go back through his posts. Almost every single one of them equivocates. "I don't know this person well enough", "this game is not as standard as I'd hoped so my reads on people I know are useless" or something to that effect. It's a recurring theme in his posts.

God forbid I don't have strong reads on Day 1 Lewwyn? Matt, yes me saying that was just the results of me getting the time at work to read Meiz's stuff and have a think about it.

Damnit, I meant Novice and not Matt above. Eugh. Quick posting FTL.

[zakalwe]

Noone except Lewwyn have offered any comment on Krill. It's as if he doesn't exist at all.

He's given a reason for not engaging D1 that I don't actually disagree with; you do get information from who the scum choose to kill N1, and with role madness there are other possible vectors to gain solid data overnight.
That, coupled with previous observation of his activities on the site (and others, related) suggesting he's a good head on his shoulders, is enough for me to not group him with those who a) had not posted at all, at the time or b) are freely lurking without giving such a concise reasoning for doing so.

On that front, Meiz has significantly ramped up his contributions since coming under fire. There mere fact of doing so isn't exactly a tell, but he's been making some decent points, which is enough to look elsewhere for now.

Molach
Claiming invincibility to everything, rapidly backing down as soon as it looked like he might actually be called on it. Even if it was a joke, it's a pretty damn poor one, given how much in this game we have to take at people's word.
The only reasoning provided for his vote on Adrien ("opportunistic") describes his own vote a lot more accurately than it does anything Adrien has done.

You didn't seem to agree with Krill earlier. (Phone so no quote.)

[Goreripper]

As an aside, with night swiftly falling like a tree, Grignr bemoaned the feast of sausages that the gathering was. The only whore to be found did not even have an opaque nose! Although she did protruberate most invitingly. Speaking of asses...
Where is the donkey? He should be concerned for his company upon the robot!

[Rowain]

You didn't seem to agree with Krill earlier. (Phone so no quote.)

Guess you mean this:

First days with no private posting in any mafia game involve lynching a random person and going from there. So do it.

We can at least focus the randomness towards people who have demonstrated a lack of interest in the general progress of the game with egregious lurking. Better than going full random and hitting someone who'd help substantially in later deduction

[Ichabod]

We can at least focus the randomness towards people who have demonstrated a lack of interest in the general progress of the game with egregious lurking. Better than going full random and hitting someone who'd help substantially in later deduction

Why, in your own words Mattimeo do you not deserve to have the same pressure applied to you? You have 3 posts so far, the least of anyone (though admittedly quality was good, as usual). There is an unsual lack of pressure being applied to you by some (Lewwyn). I suppose you haven't had any votes for you so far (that I can see) but the lack of need to defend yourself isn't exactly a reason to disengage!

Additionally, dont believe in Molach/Moses immune claim - would be weird. Scummy.
Jowy & Ichibod did little but respond to their initial pressure late (which i suppose is what you do) and then Jowy diverting with discussions on post restrictions.

Again, I'm happy to switch and would like more discussion!

I read Meiz's posts and didn't see much but will take a fresh view near lunch.

meta: I'll be around tonight for the vote (I THINK, but will be packing) and then flying most of tomorrow/thursday to 'Straya.

Holy crap, this is all sorts of phony. Like those bores that get up in class just to point out to the teacher and the class that they read this and that book, when in fact they didn't understand shit about it, they just read them so they could look like a smartass to everyone else. You just said a lot of things that appear content, but this whole post is incredibly empty, really. And what's with the vote on Mattimeo, that has quality posts, you said so yourself, only to basically say below that you want to switch of him?

And no one's voting for this guy? People never notice anything...

Shadeun

[Gazglum]

Im phoning it in. too. Meiz, I have no other strong suspects. Krill refuses to engage but it fits his.civ persona. Off top of my head, novice is a bit laissez faire, shadeun going hot and cold on whether to use influence to guide his vote, and feels like bob has slid back to the shadows after entertaining first day. But I wouldnt vote any of them over molach. Adrien I think is top poster, in. his fVour.

Missed drone game, but in. this case I would be one of three drones, so not really an analogy.