WW16: The Outlaws and The Olives

[Meiz]

This late in the day and a case against a previously rarely mentioned player forms... It's strange.

I've had him targeted the better part of the game. Day 4 made me think him as villager, but not so sure anymore.

[Selrahc]

I'll also go for Tasunke. Everybody else... eh. Not feeling it. I doubt that the Meiz lynch will resolve the question of a Post Restrictor to anybodies satisfaction, even if he is a wolf.

[Injera]

I fail to see how I'm shady, just trying some different stuff, but whatever.

"Trying different stuff" + diffidence = a confused approach to the game. Or whatever.

My two cents on waterbat:

I did think his post backing off his vote on me was really weird, apologetic and thanking me for defending, but at the time I chalked it up to was because his vote on me was more of an unspoken revenge vote based on me unfairly criticizing him not updating his scraper in my last minute post the night before.

I think his non-vote on Day 2 is just bizarre and never really got a good explanation, one that didn't help because I misread it at first and was asking the wrong questions, but it seemed unusual at the time to vote mayor while making a fake vote for the lynch. Especially since the mayoral vote would have swung the vote differently than his fake vote would have.

x-post

[Ichabod]

I've had him targeted the better part of the game. Day 4 made me think him as villager, but not so sure anymore.

Sorry, that's definetely true.

[Ichabod]

Lynch Vote Count

Meiz - 5 - Azza, Ichabod, tasunke, Gaspar, Twinkletoes89
Selrahc - 4 - Meiz, Waterbat, Molach, Jkaen
Waterbat - 3 - novice, Pindicator, Selrahc
Azza - 2 - Catwalk, Lewwyn
tasunke - 1 - Injera

Players not voting: None

[Catwalk]

I'm not keen on lynching Meiz or Waterbat. I would prefer Azza, Tasunke, Ichabod and Selrahc in that order.

[Catwalk]

And throw in pindicator somewhere in the last 3. Would much prefer Azza or Tasunke, though.

[Injera]

Argh, this game. I'm kinda suspicious that the fact that Meiz made that post against waterbat then backed off when the votes starting falling meant it was meant as distancing.

[pindicator]

I've had him targeted the better part of the game. Day 4 made me think him as villager, but not so sure anymore.

Wait, are you talking about me?

So you don't like that I followed you on your analysis of waterbat? And if you thought I was a villager day 4, why were you voting for me on day 5?

I think I called it earlier in the day:

Personally I think very few of the villagers trust me and so any thoughts they have on a player gets colored by my votes.

[Meiz]

Argh, this game. I'm kinda suspicious that the fact that Meiz made that post against waterbat then backed off when the votes starting falling meant it was meant as distancing.

(directed at me :D). It's the same as with Pindicator's case. A lot of moving parts to make it work, and I'd rather take the straight forward case of lurking scum (Selrahc or Azza). I will vote waterbat if his defense is not good (he's online) and it's a chance to save myself.