Posts: 8,022
Threads: 37
Joined: Jan 2006
novice Wrote:That's an interesting post, Gaspar. One of my impressions of Waterbat is that he's good at participating in the lynch discussions and has voted correctly some times (although not on Thestick), but he doesn't really bring many new suspects to the table. That's my impression at least.
Waterbat certainly could be scum - but he's definitely not lynchbait. I've generally found myself nodding along to his thoughts, though naturally given our current line of discussion I think he's good enough to fake that. Still, he wouldn't be a first target for me.
Posts: 12,335
Threads: 46
Joined: Jan 2011
Ichabod Wrote:I'll answer your question near the deadline.
 Like you need to fear death from your wolf-buddies.
“The wind went mute and the trees in the forest stood still. It was time for the last tale.”
Posts: 12,335
Threads: 46
Joined: Jan 2011
Gaspar Wrote:Waterbat certainly could be scum - but he's definitely not lynchbait. I've generally found myself nodding along to his thoughts, though naturally given our current line of discussion I think he's good enough to fake that. Still, he wouldn't be a first target for me.
Nah, waterbat's gotta be innocent based on the rereading I did of him a few days ago. I don't see a wolf's consistency or studied affect. Instead it's much more free flowing and un-apprehensive.
“The wind went mute and the trees in the forest stood still. It was time for the last tale.”
Posts: 9,706
Threads: 69
Joined: Dec 2010
Lewwyn Wrote:That's fine Ichabod. That basically confirms exactly what I thought you were trying to do and manipulate the lynch. Personally I think that you had a different motivation from the one you are expressing, IE: lynch Meiz, and more of "lynch anyone but wolf buddy".
I keep thinking about WW3, because I just keep seeing parallels. I think today's lynch matches up pretty closely with the Fire&Ice lynch in which we had 2 wolves on the block in Scooter and Zak but end up lynching the villager because Roland barrels in at the last second and blows up the vote.
Also if I remember right, Ichabod, you put the final vote to seal my lynch and leave the village with a final mislynch. I'm not eager to see history repeat itself.
And I was a villager in that game.
And who was the second wolf yesterday? Selrahc? Meiz?
How can you be singing the same tune for the whole game, oh, so confident, with all the things that have been happening?
Posts: 12,335
Threads: 46
Joined: Jan 2011
Ichabod Wrote:And I was a villager in that game.
And who was the second wolf yesterday? Selrahc? Meiz?
How can you be singing the same tune for the whole game, oh, so confident, with all the things that have been happening?
I know you were a villager in that game.
I think there's a good possibility that there was a second wolf in Selrahc. I think it's telling that you were aiming to lynch Meiz or Tasunke but no one else. Mostly because I really think there were wolves on the block.
What do you mean the same tune? Confident? Things that have been happening? I sincerely don't get your meaning here because I've been up and down all game.
“The wind went mute and the trees in the forest stood still. It was time for the last tale.”
Posts: 9,706
Threads: 69
Joined: Dec 2010
Lewwyn Wrote:I know you were a villager in that game.
I think there's a good possibility that there was a second wolf in Selrahc. I think it's telling that you were aiming to lynch Meiz or Tasunke but no one else. Mostly because I really think there were wolves on the block.
What do you mean the same tune? Confident? Things that have been happening? I sincerely don't get your meaning here because I've been up and down all game.
As I can recall, you only suspected the same players through the whole game. How come you didn't say anything about the PRs, about players like Novice, meiz, Gaspar, Pindicator?
Whatever, lewwyn, my only choices with regard to you are ignore you or vote to lynch you. I see you are already convinced about me and you just keep fitting things as they come along. Just need to think if hat's honest misguided villager or annoying wolf.
Posts: 12,335
Threads: 46
Joined: Jan 2011
Ichabod Wrote:As I can recall, you only suspected the same players through the whole game. How come you didn't say anything about the PRs, about players like Novice, meiz, Gaspar, Pindicator?
PRs I have mentioned are foolish to even both with because they are just the wolves playing tricks with us. Simply go with your reads and ignore the PRs. I know I've stated this back in the beginning when Novice was PRed and I haven't talked about it because I think its simply a distraction.
Novice. Yeah I've been "singing the same tune" about him I've said on multiple occasions that I trust novice and I'm not buying into the tinfoil. Meiz I have also stated the same thing. Gaspar is someone I sparred with just two days ago but then I went after you and my suspicion has only grown so maybe I need to revisit Gaspar, that's a fair criticism. Truth be told though he's been sounding more like the Gaspar of WW games past. Didn't I talk about him being like his Perpy self earlier this game? Pindicator is such a friggin' grey area. Honestly I can't tell, either way I don't think it harms us to keep him alive while we lynch people I'm more suspicious of.
I've suspected numerous players throughout the game, problem is they never die(you, Selrahc), or they become obvious villagers (Catwalk, Waterbat). So yes I still suspect you Ichabod. You drifted less suspicious for a while but now you're right back in it.
See again. You keep doing this Ichabod. You keep saying I haven't done things when I have, and that I have done things that I haven't. I can't tell if it's you misunterstanding or misremembering or being a lazy wolf. Problem for me is you've been doing this twisting thing since Day 2. You did it then and then when I came back to you on Day 5 you did it again. Now you're doing it here. I understand this game is huge and things can get (we've topped 3k posts in this thread now) but I keep feeling like you're twisting arguments to suit your needs. Especially when you say things like, "How can you be singing the same tune for the whole game, oh, so confident, with all the things that have been happening?" It's just so blatantly open ended and scummily smearing.
“The wind went mute and the trees in the forest stood still. It was time for the last tale.”
Posts: 12,335
Threads: 46
Joined: Jan 2011
I've been missing a bit of this back and forth this game. I'm always going to bed before Ichabod get's on and waking up after he goes to sleep so there's just not a lot of overlap. Having exchange helps clarify things for me. Soldifies my opinions and makes me comfortable for a change.
Its 3 am and I'm dropping fast. Tomorrow's a new day. I think my death wish is known at this point.
“The wind went mute and the trees in the forest stood still. It was time for the last tale.”
Posts: 17,503
Threads: 78
Joined: Nov 2005
Okay, this pisses me off upon re-reading the night convos. How many people were calling the end of day play stupid? And then of those people how many just sat on the sidelines with their own thoughts?
Which also seems like an easy way for someone who is scum to give "input": you jump at the chance to foster dissent and suspicion, but dont feel the same need to add to any discussion
Suffer Game Sicko
Dodo Tier Player
Posts: 13,563
Threads: 49
Joined: Oct 2009
waterbat Wrote:i am an idiot. This one is on me guys.
I stated in the thread that when meiz got to the lead we all of a sudden had breakout wagons. And Selrahc on those wagons.
so.... i could have easily voted for either of those guys, but no..... i vote for the new candidate that i thought could easily be wolf and it didnt look like the wolves had time to react to it. If I had known there were going to be more Azza votes, i would have went there.
Either way, i am offended at my own existance right now.
After WW14's endgame you were positively frothing. How could you be so sanguine today? Even to the point of taking personal responsibility for the mislynch? This seems insincere to me.
(Yes, no good deed goes unpunished...)
I have to run.
|
