WW8: Madness in Outer Space (game thread - players only)

[Lewwyn]

Well well well... Do we have two baners, Catwalk?

Seriously.

[Catwalk]

My ability was different in that it inflicted a wound on the target, rather than myself. The wound would only be inflicted in case the target was an attempted night kill, same as Serdoa's ability.

[Lewwyn]

My ability was different in that it inflicted a wound on the target, rather than myself. The wound would only be inflicted in case the target was an attempted night kill, same as Serdoa's ability.

Thats... actually reasonable.

[Catwalk]

It's bad luck that a baner gets eaten right after I claimed, but at least I did claim before I knew that. And with every villager seemingly having a small one-shot ability, it's not entirely implausible to have two baners. The difference between them could have been a little more interesting, but zakalwe was probably having a hard time coming up with something unique for each of us.

I won't claim that this clears me, but I'd like to request to at least not be made top suspect for today. If you still suspect me, try to have me hung tomorrow if you still find me suspicious then.

[Lewwyn]

This is my thinking as of right now.

[COLOR="DarkGreen"]Innocent:
Lewwyn[/COLOR]

[COLOR="PaleGreen"]Probable innocent:
Novice
Catwalk[/COLOR]

[COLOR="Gray"]Gray:
Rowain[/COLOR]

[COLOR="Red"]Possible scum:
Uberfish
Sareln
Erebus[/COLOR]

[Catwalk]

I agree with your list, and I think chances are really good that 2 out of the bottom 3 are scum. That's still a 1/3 miss rate, though. Who do you suspect the most? You're still somewhere between my gray and red list, btw.

[Lewwyn]

Sareln is skating way too low guys. He didn't even cast a vote yesterday even though he posted. He never cast a single vote. I mean if I were scum I'd want to play as far back as possible. I am very suspicious of it.

[Catwalk]

The same can be said of Erebus. Btw both were low-ish activity last game, and both were innocent. Erebus stands out to me as contributing the least out of the two, read through his early posts and there's almost nothing there.

[Lewwyn]

The same can be said of Erebus. Btw both were low-ish activity last game, and both were innocent. Erebus stands out to me as contributing the least out of the two, read through his early posts and there's almost nothing there.

I agree with that. My issue is that Erebus at least voted. Sareln didn't even do that.

[Catwalk]

I think both are good bets, but I'd rather go by post content than voting. It's reasonable to argue that several players are put off by the voting system and display.... erratic behaviour I might be crazy for defending your vote yesterday, it was so amazingly anti-town.